Players of Bygone Days
Mr. .Murpliy dismisses some of the grealesl
players llial ever have appeared on a North
Carolina gridiron. See if you agree with
Ии»
selections he makes.
Kff WAI/l'KIt (“Pete”) Ml III* II V
1IIAYE often been requested to
name an all-time team from North
Carolina colleges, and just as often
I have refused. Now. just after the
close of the season of 1941. my mind
reverts to the past and as I envision
the teams from 1SS9 down to the year
just closed, T feel moved to say
a few words about two teams which
to my mind were the best of all time
in North Carolina; two teams which
played for ninety minutes in every
game, with no substitution and a few
minutes of rest at intermission, and
often engaged in contests as frequently
as three games or more per week.
To pick an all-time team would in¬
vite gome criticism and much dissent,
so I will, in the main confine my re¬
marks to the two teams suggested
above. These two teams were the
Trinity (now Duke) of 1S91, and Car¬
olina's team of 1S92.
I have seen in action every team
that Carolina, Trinity, Wake Forest,
State and Davidson have ever had on
the field, nnd in some small degree 1
am qualified by observation and ex¬
perience to present my views.
I am rather pressed to do so, in
fact, after reading a clipping from a
newspaper sent me by a former groat
athlete now living in Eastern Caro¬
lina, which proclaimed that, “the old-
time teams would be helpless in con¬
test with the modern teams, which
could lick them by any score which
they saw fit to impose.”
Expressing it Mildly
Such n statement is the opinion of
юте
clabber-brained ass who spouts
his wisdom on the natives ns if it.
were an indisputable fact, and should
he dismissed as the vaporings of an
idle brain.
Both Trinity ’91 and Carolina '92
made their records within the space of
three years after football had been
introduced in North Carolina. Either
of these teams could lick the bloomin’
boots off of any team which has been
on the field in the years since.
Taking them in order, let us look at
Trinity :
I knew each man on this team;
some of them are still with us; many
have passed on. The roster of the
squad was as follows: Rolwrt I-ee.
Stonewall Jackson, and Plato Dur¬
ham (brothers), Erwin Avery, Fred
Harper, Tom Daniels, Billy McDow¬
ell, Jake Hanes, Jesse James (not the
bandit), Luther Hnrtsell, M. T. l'lv-
lor, D. W. Caviness, Will Flowers,
Bon Black, Pink Turner, Carl"
Bandy and W. S. Whitaker. Of these
Plato Durham, Erwin Avery, Will
Flowers, Pink Turner and Whitaker
have answered the last summons.
Fred Harper was the finest of all the
quarterbacks I have ever seen. Torn
Daniels was the fastest haekfield man
ever on any gridiron in North Caro¬
lina, ami Bob Durham was the finest
punter and general toe artist of all.
Capable Players
All of these men were finished play¬
ers, capable of playing a much more
strenuous game of ninety minutes
than one sees in the modern game,
and this modern game, to uiy mind,
is a combination of football, basket¬
ball and tag, in no wise requiring tin?
iron men of bygone days. At the pres¬
ent time one often sees a statement
to the effect that "Slugger" Jones
has played as much as a hundred and
fifty minutes during the present - a-
son. In the olden days most of the
teams, intact, played that time in two
games; in fact the Trinity team of '91
played the whole season for ninety
minutes in each game. There are ninny
men now living who were in many
games for ninety minutes of service
each. Several played as much as live
years of varsity football.
A JEFFERSON STANDARD
POLICY
Isa Declaration of Independence
for the Font ily
I think that Tom Daniels of Trin¬
ity played seven full years of sched¬
uled games without ever leaving the
field during a single game.
In my opinion, one could pick a
team from those old teams and put a
team on the field that would Ik? in¬
vincible.
The Carolina team of 1892 was as
follows: Michael Hoke, Crawford
Biggs, William A. Devin. Alfred
Barnard, E. M. Snipes, W. I>. Mor
rill, J. T. Pugh, Boscoe Little, II. B.
Shaw, David Kirkpatrick, Charles
Baskerville, N. M. Gibbs. Pat Stanly,
Louis Guion and myself; W. P.
Wooten, sub-Center.
The team lined up with Hoke as
captain, Barnard, quarter. Bigg, and
Gibbs, ends; Pugh and Little, tackles;
Snipes and Kirkpatrick, guards; Dev¬
in, Hoke. Baskerville. in the bark-
field; and Murphy, center.
Barnard was the best extra-point
player I ever saw. In 1892, by his toe,
lie added fifty-eight extra points to
Carolina's score. At that time the ball
was brought out ou the field from the
point from which the touchdown was
made, and the try for extra point was
made from that place which very often
was an acute angle and not directly
in front of the goal as it is at present.
There are a few positions on an all-
timo team I would name: at center,
“Mink" Cunninggim of Carolina or
Dan Hill of Trinity-Duke; in the
haekfield, Boh Durham of Trinity, ami
Arthur Bolden of Carolina (these two
were the most skillful toe-artists ever
on a Carolina gridiron); at quarter.
A If Barnard of Carolina, or Fred
Harper of Trinity. Thus far 1 go.
An All-Time Team
However, I can name a sound from
which an all-time team could he eas¬
ily pieked and it would be as follows:
Haekfield, Tom Daniels, Bob Durham,
Fred IIar|M«r, Alf Barnard, George
Stevens, Arthur Bolden. Mike Hoke.
Hunter Carpenter, Boy Ahcrnathv.
and Bill Jacob. Take’ any four of
( Continued on page hrenlg-fire)