I
Mutiny and Murder
On the High Seas
board by the mutineers who were
led by the big and brutal Scott.
The legal battle for the lives of
the three mutineers was fought in
the U. S. District courtroom which
was then located on the upper
lioor of the old brownstone post-
oflice building in Wilmington. This
structure was razed some years
ago and a more modern building
erected. Judge Thomas R. Purnell,
of Raleigh, central figure in the
contempt proceedings against the
late Josephus Daniels (which at¬
tracted wide attention at the time)
presided over the trial. The prose¬
cution was conducted by Harry
Skinner, of Greenville, then U. S.
District Attorney. William J. Bel¬
lamy, a prominent lawyer of Wil¬
mington, who. was recognized as
the possessor of one of the most
brilliant legal minds at the bar, de¬
fended Scott. George I.. Peschau,
another skilled criminal lawyer of
Wilmington, served as counsel for
Adams and Sawyer.
Captain John William Taylor,
master of the American schooner.
Blanche H. King, which was
owned by the same company that
owned the Berwind, testified that
his lookout reported at 9 o'clock
on the night of October 10 that a
nearby schooner was acting in an
unusual manner, was flying dis¬
tress signals and was apparently
ofT its course.
Captain Taylor said that when
his boarding party reached the
Berwind , one of the Negroes
aboard declared that a man had
killed the captain, mate, steward,
engineer, and a sailor. Captain
Taylor said that the boarding
party found Scott bound with
ropes, and that the
body of Coakley
was lying prone on
the deck. Scott at
first denied the
charges which other
members of the
crew made against
him, but later con¬
fessed that he had
committed the mur¬
ders single-handed
with his revolver.
One» of I ho most bruin I ocour-
renoos ovor to have takon place
on the high seas. It occurred
off the coast of North Carolina,
anil the final chapter was writ¬
ten in Wilmington.
tty LOUIS T. .WOO ict:
All Three Jailed
Scott, Adams, and
Sawyer were placed
in jail in Wilming¬
ton. The trial took
place and all three
were found guilty of
murder in the first
degree and were
THE STATE. February 14. 1048
IN the minds of two generations
of North Carolinians, including
those now nearly fifty years old,
mention of the schooner, Berwind
and the names of Henry Scott, Ar¬
thur Adams, and Robert Sawyer
probably will bring no mental re¬
action whatsoever. Yet less than
half a century ago this ship was
the scene of the bloodiest mutiny
and murders of modern times on
the high seas.
The crime resulted in the death
of the captain, three other officers
and a seaman. The slaughter of the
quintet occurred off the coast of
North Carolina. The death ship
later was brought into Southport,
with Scott. Adams, and Sawyer in
chains. Later Scott confessed that
he alone had committed the mur¬
ders. For his crime, he was hanged
in New Hanover County jail in
Wilmington after trial in the U. S.
District Court. On the strength of
the confession made by Scott im¬
mediately before his
execution, Adams
and Sawyer, whose
sentence had been
commuted to life
imprisonment, were
granted pardons by
President William
Howard Taft after
having served only
a short portion of
their sentence.
wrongs and who turned into a
raging beast. Because of the na¬
tional horror that followed dis¬
closure of the crime, and also
because part of the drama took
place in North Carolina, those who
never have heard of the episode
may be interested in reading
about it.
The mute evidence of the trag¬
edy was found on the blood¬
stained decks when the Berwind
was towed into the harbor at
Southport in October, 1905. Three
members of the crew — Scott,
Adams, and Sawyer (all Negroes)
were immediately • arrested by a
U. S. Deputy Marshal and charged
with the murder of the captain,
the mate, the engineer, the stew¬
ard. and a Negro seaman named
Coakley whose body still lay upon
the deck.
The bodies of Captain E. R.
Rumill. Mate John T. Hall. Stew¬
ard John Faldc and Engineer
C. L. Smith had been tossed over¬
Tragedy In Its
Worst Form
This story of mur¬
der aboard the Ber¬
wind reveals stark
and grim tragedy in
its most desperate
form. It has to do
with a man who
went berserk be¬
cause of fancied
The waterfront at Southport.