Ten Primates in
Public Service
Mr. Lawrence submit* a list of ten
North Carolinians who have dis¬
tinguished themselves by holding
the highest public offices in the
nation.
»;/
R. C. LAWRENCE
I AM listing below the names
of the ten Carolinians who have
held the highest public offices
on the field of the nation. This
list does not include Presidents
Jackson. Polk and Johnson be¬
cause. although they were natives
of our State, they were residents
of other States when elected to the
presidency; and for the same
reason vice president William
Rufus King and Ambassadors
Walter Hines Page. Robert Worth
Bingham and Walter E. Dodd are
not included.
James Iredell. Sr., of Chowan,
Associate Justice of the Supreme
Court of the United States, for
whom Iredell County was named.
Resident of Edenton, he was easily
the ablest lawyer of his generation,
and he led the fight in the Hills¬
boro Convention for the ratifica¬
tion of the Federal Constitution.
This may account for the fact that
in 1790. without his knowledge,
he was appointed to our highest
court by President Washington,
who was an ardent advocate of
the ratification of the instrument
declared by the great English
statesman Gladstone to have been
“the greatest instrument ever
struck off by the hand of man."
Iredell’s name will be forever as¬
sociated with that historic docu¬
ment for it was his famous dissent¬
ing opinion in Chisholm v. Georgia
which led to the adoption of the
eleventh amendment, which pro¬
vides that a State cannot be sued
without its consent. He was the
father of James Iredell. Jr., con¬
sidered by some historians as a
greater lawyer than his father, who
carved out quite a career for him¬
self. serving as Judge, Speaker of
the Commons. Governor and
United States Senator. The con¬
nection of the elder Iredell with
the Constitution should serve to
recall the fact that only one other
Carolinian’s name has been con¬
nected with that document. Fed¬
eral Judge Yates Webb being the
original author of the eighteenth
amendment.
Alfred Moore, of Brunswick. As¬
sociate Justice of the Supreme
Court of the United States, for
whom Moore County and Moore
Square in Raleigh were named.
He came of a distinguished family,
served as an officer during the
Revolution, and rapidly rose to
eminence at the Carolina Bar,
serving as Attorney General. He
followed the famous Iredell upon
the bench of our highest court, and
was our last representative there¬
on. He served only a few years
and wrote but few opinions, as in
those early years there was little
litigation to occupy the time of
the court, and the day of John
Marshall was not yet at hand when
he established the power of the
court to set aside an act of Con¬
gress as unconstitutional. Several
early members of the court re¬
signed to accept offices now con¬
sidered as of inferior dignity, such
as Justice Rutledge, who resigned
to accept appointment as a Justice
of the Supreme Court of South
Carolina, and Justice Harrison who
resigned tp accept appointment as
Comptroller of New Jersey.
Only two other Carolinians have
ever had any connection with our
highest court, Judge George E.
Badger, whose career is listed be¬
low; and Circuit Judge John J.
Parker, who was nominated to
that high office but who failed of
confirmation by the narrow margin
of just one vote. And how he
would have graced that bench!
John Branch, of Halifax. Secre¬
tary of the Navy. When President
Andrew Jackson rose to political
power, he recognized the State of
his nativity by naming this emi¬
nent Carolinian and outstanding
Congressman as a member of his
Cabinet, the first Carolinian to be
thus honored; and the precedent
thus established has been adhered
to ever since, as the only Cabinet
post to be held by a Carolinian has
been that of Secretory of the Navy,
which premier position has been
held by five of our sons. Branch
was not happy in his high office,
as he soon found himself at odds
with “Old Hickory” over a ques¬
tion not of political but of social
importance. One of Jackson's cabi¬
net. Secretary Eaton, had married
pretty Peggy O’Neill, daughter of
a Washington tavern keeper, and
official Washington society de¬
clined to receive or accept her
socially. Our gallant, if plebeian
born President promptly declared
that Pretty Peggy must be accorded
official and social recognition: and
as a protest against this action
several members of the cabinet re¬
signed. including Secretary Branch.
This protest had not the least ef¬
fect upon Old Hickory, who stood
by pretty Peggy to the end and
retained her husband as a member
of his official family. His own
Rachael had been talked about
herself by the elite of society!
James C. Dobbin, of Cumber¬
land, Secretary of the Navy, ap¬
pointed in 1852. Dobbin was
Speaker of the House of Commons
at the time Dorothea Dix came to
our State to try to induce the
legislature to establish a hospital
for the care of those mentally af¬
flicted, but the measure which she
championed, and which received
the support of Governor Graham,
was defeated by an overwhelming
vote. A few days later the wife of
Speaker Dobbin was seized with
what proved a fatal illness, during
which she was tenderly nursed by
Miss Dix. and just before she died
Mrs. Dobbin extracted a promise
from her husband that he would
exhaust his efforts to get the bill
espoused by Miss Dix enacted into
law. Two days after her death.
Speaker Dobbin moved reconsider¬
ation of the vote by which her
bill had been defeated; and he
supported his motion by a speech
of such moving eloquence and
pathos that the House reversed its
action by a vote of 91 to 10— one
of the most amazing reversals in
legislative history; and moreover
the speech had such a profound ef¬
fect that when the bill got over in
( Continued on page 20)