A Case For O. Henry
A story, after all. Is a ••story” — yet his treat
an encompassing truth.
tty SHELBY STEP II E\SO.\
h is lime for a revival of inleresl in
North Carolina's William Sydney
Porter, popularly known as O. Henry'.
Born in Greensboro in 1962. he is
buried in Riverside Cemetery near
Asheville — his grave not far from
Thomas Wolfe's. (Porter’s second
w ife. Sara Lindsay Coleman, was from
Weavervillc.)
After 0. Henry’s death in 1910. his
popularity developed into an industry’.
Eugene Currcnt-Garcia wrote in the O.
HENRY. Twayne’s United States
Authors' Series. 1965: "No other
American writer of stories had ever
been so widely read, enjoyed, dis¬
cussed. approved of. and imitated.”
Along came the new criticism w ith its
dictum that a work of art is an object in
itself. O. Henry's endings, new critics
argued, were not prepared for and
were nol organic parts of the stories.
Moreover, the writers stirring the
world one decade after (). Henry's
death included those great American
twentieth-century experimenters in
form — Sherwood Anderson. Ernest
Hemingway. William Faulkner, and
F. Scott Fitzgerald. These writers
wrote about the deep and tragic loneli¬
ness of people and they found new
ways — points of view — to present
them. And the name O. Henry faded
into obscurity.
Old South vs New South
Many of his approximately 250 short
stories are set in the South and several
in his native state. These stories ex¬
ploit the theme of the old South versus
the new: "The Guardian of the Ac¬
colade." "The Emancipation of
Billy." and "A Blackjack Bargainer."
They present a "professional South¬
erner." an old southern gentleman-
type. in contrast to a changing, unsure
kind of character w ho wants to move
on into the twentieth century.
This old South-new South theme is
part of O. Henry's larger concern and
overall theme — the effect and con¬
sequences of coincidence on charac¬
ter. His dominant attitude is the fa¬
mous entertaining humor, often
grotesque and ironic, as in "The Guar¬
dian of the Accolade." when Uncle
Bushrod. an old black guardian of the
THE STATE, March 1982
Weymouth family, tries to preserve
the family honor of his boss. Robert
Weymouth, president of the bank, by
making him give up a suitcase before
boarding a train. Uncle Bushrod had
seen his boss stuffing the suitcase in
the bank vault. Bushrod gets the case.
Weymouth goes on a vacation to fish,
confessing on arrival that he has lost it.
Back home Bushrod says the suitcase
contained "two quarts of the finest old
silk-velvet bourbon . . . you ever wet
your lips with." The touches for which
(). Henry is known are here — the
surprise ending, the contrived de¬
scription and dialogue. There is nos¬
talgia for the past — a sentimental,
tenderly rendered attitude toward an
unredeemable past resolved with a
self-conscious humor. The artiness —
the contrived quality, dominates.
Manipulation and Irony
So also with "The Emancipation of
Billy." The conflict between the old
South and new comes out in the re¬
lationship between the aged Pember¬
ton. a Civil War hero, and his son Billy,
a forty-two-year-old lawyer who has
gained a national reputation by win¬
ning many cases before the United
States Supreme Court. The question is
w ill Billy take a federal judgeship or
turn the chance down to remain the
"son of* his father forever. Will Billy
preserve family and the old order? All
the citizens of Hlmvillc gather to hear
Billy's decision. Everybody thinks he
will turn down the assignment and re¬
main in his father's shadow. He takes
the judgeship. asO. Henry's technique
of manipulation and irony rule again.
Ironic humor is the main charac¬
teristic of "A Blackjack Bargainer."
Set in western North Carolina, the
story concerns a once wealthy, suc¬
cessful lawyer Yancy Goree who
drinks and gambles away the family
estate, finally even selling the rights to
a long-standing feud between his fam¬
ily and the Coltranes. The buyer of the
estate and the right to the feud is one
Pike Garvey, a squirrel-hunter who
"acknowledged no occupation save
that of a squirrel hunter, but he moon-
shined occasionally by way of diver¬
sion. Once the revenues' had dragged
him from his lair, fighting silently and
desperately like a terrier, and he had
been sent to state’s prison for two
years. Released, he popped back into
his hole like an angry weasel." Yancy
arranges for Pike Garvey to kill him as
he rides Coltrane's horse. Since Yancy
is wearing Coltrane s jacket and looks
like Coltrane from a distance. Pike
Garvey thinks he is actually shooting
Coltrane. The feud over and Yancy
Goree dead, the hackwoodsy Garvey
wants no part of civilization and goes
back to the woods.
Like all of (). Henry's stories, these
three display the triumph of humor and
comedy over matter. Another example
is "Let Me Feel Your Pulse." writ¬
ten right before he died. Also set in
western North Carolina, this auto¬
biographical story is about an alcohol¬
ic who comes from the Catskills to
Pincyvillc to try to get himself to¬
gether. The doctor tells him he can he
cured if he finds an Amaryllis in the
shade. The alcoholic learns that the
mind’s natural high, the imagination, is
superior to any lift whiskey can give.
Since World War II. parody, humor,
and satire have almost dominated fic¬
tion: these traits also characterize
O. Henry’s writings. With his self-con¬
scious humor, stereotypes, contrived
plots. (). Henry never lets his reader
forget that a story, after all. is a
"story.” something made up. Yet his
stories treat an encompassing truth we
Teed to remember: human experience
edeems itself.
13