Tar Heel History
By Billy Arthur
Banjo Man
Jackson County's Felix Ray Alley gained notice as a lawyer,
judge and author, but he was most famous for a song he
picked on his banjo about a promising dance gone sour.
Felix Eugene Alley rose from a log
cabin to distinction as a lawyer
Superior Conn judge, author and
eloquent orator Not only that, but as a
mountain lad lie taught himself to play a
banjo with strings of common sewing
thread and at age 16 composed the
famous "Ballad of Kidder Cole." which
now is part of state and national folklore.
The youngest of 10 children of
Colonel John H. Alley and Sarah
Whiteside Norton Alley. Felix was bom
July 5. 1873, in the Whiteside Cove area
of Jackson County. His father fought in
the Mexican and Civil Wars, and his
mother was the first white child bom in
that heavily populated Indian area.
When Felix was about 10 years old. a
brother made for him a banjo from a cir¬
cular wooden cheese hoop, over which
was stretched a tanned groundhog skin.
The neck and keys were hand-carved
with a jackknife, and the strings were
made of twisted J&P Coats S|m>oI Cotton
thread.
In a 1933 interview with the Asheville
Citizen, Judge Alley explained how he
wrote what was once the most popular
banjo tune in the land. “I took the instru¬
ment to my heart.” he told the newspa¬
per. “and straightaway learned to pick
out tunes and soon could play on it all
the ones I knew."
One summer a Rood deluged the
Cashiers Valley, and a man named Childs
and his sister, both of New York, were
watcT-tround in the Alley home several
days, waiting for the streams to subside so
they could c ross the fords. There were no
bridges. For them, time passed slowly.
One day the man saw the homemade
banjo and asked young Felix to play it.
I le consented but advised that he would
first have to replace a broken string.
From his mother's sewing basket, he
quickly obtained a spool of J&P Coals
thread, made and waxed a string from a
rkM»«Hiiirn<4 N C Dm—
ш Ы
AnhKnmt III— m
Felix Ray AlUy
length of it and played for the guests
everything he knew.
Meanwhile, the man “seemed to
heartily enjoy" the music, examined the
spool of thread and revealed he was an
official in the Coals company, en route
back to New York after a Southern adver¬
tising trip. He then said jokingly, accord¬
ing to Judge Alley. “I knew the thread was
good for many things, but never before
that it was good for banjo strings." And
he then promised to send young Felix a
set of real banjo strings and a box of
thread for his mother when he got back
to New York.
The box of thread came annually
almost the remainder of her life.
A short while after the man left. Felix
received by express at Walhalla, South
Carolina, (the nearest post office 35
miles distant) “a very expensive banjo . .
. several eel skin heads and enough
string to last me from that time on . . .
(We) kept up correspondence until his
death some years later."
To indicate the strength of the thread
young Felix had been using, an advertis¬
ing card at the time pictured a barefoot
boy on the edge of a stream about to fish
Thf StalrOrtobcr 1995
14
with a line made of the thread. In his
book. Random Thoughts and Musings of a
Mountaineer, ; published in 1941. Judge
Alley wrote that he was later advised by
Childs that the company was changing
the picture to depict a barefoot boy play¬
ing a banjo with cotton thread strings. In
1983. the company, at this writer's
request, was unable to locate the revised
card in its advertising files of 1875-1900.
but that in no way detracts from Judge
Alley's original use of the thread for
strings or the annual gilt to his mother.
In the same year (1983), Betty Gene
Alley, a granddaughter, wrote: "I am
aware that after his retirement from the
bench, he continued to receive his annu¬
al Christmas gift of Coats' and Clarks'
newest spools of thread, with which my
grandmother made her quilts."
Now about the ballad composed by the
teenager Alley.
“Miss Kidder Cole was the daughter of
George M. Cole, a merchant living in the
same township." Judge Aliev1 recalled for
the Asheville Citizen interview. “She was
about my age and conceded by everyone
to lx- the beauty of the mountains. The
occasion that inspired the little ballad
was an all-night dance. I had been going
to some of the dances and had danced
with Miss Kidder Cole. I had planned
that night to dance with her all night
long. I lowever, 1 was a little late, and the
dance was in full swing. Through the
doorway I saw, to my bitter disappoint¬
ment. that my cousin. Charley Wright,
had already claimed the lass as a partner
— and he danced with her the whole
night through."
I laving become "quite an artist on the
city-bought banjo." Alley began compos¬
ing the ballad that night. At the time he
was in demand to furnish music for
square dances in Transylvania, Macon
and Jackson counties, plus the nearby
border counties in Georgia and South
Carolina. “‘Kidder Cole’ quickly became
popular." Alley said, "for I composed it
for a catchy tunc and the words struck a
responsive chord in the heart of youth,
especially since many knew the girl and
her suitors.
“Like all banjo songs, it has gone the
rounds, and 1 have had men tell me from
more than 18 states that for years they
have heard the ballad sung and the tune
played by banjoists in their states.”
Variously revised by musicians and lyri-