w u \ x £ ii v * fk-c n t*z \ it i ev-ti u-iso to abstain from lavs s-hich h iwr-r vi.t nl - . . i i . • . * n---lv,_s nt n ■■ n.i fee of inequality whioh iiml no response it the heart ol the citiaen and which will taeraded with little remon bhe - 1 loin 1 i si aii ii is especially seen in rafting law on conscience dr chaining i ui ill'ilv cluigk salisbury tt©w gdi cy v (' .. i>*.u puit 13 ia l\0l ii i union f mai nil i.»t of individuals ; thu ii ii forine i by the si u-s 1 . . . l that the citizens •-( lho in v.ir.tl states were i und lo it through lhe acts of ih.-ir s.-r mi til-its ' 1 ji.il ■- •:■ ' illli.'il iim ' 1 itituti'iti for itself and th.it 11 was ullj hv such ratificalii.il uf a state that any oh ltti;|t|.ml wils .-,.., ,-..'.! i|h lie 1117 is — thus believing it was lho opinion i the i.'i.|ilii fl r ll a tn.'t il l"l hui . i in 111 sii.t wiu.'li had imposed iho uhlifeutirtu 1 . 1 ichtre 1,1 ilh ischi resort th extent nf iiat obligation bb'jht'-sa her citizens were , , ., in i : in i ibis upon tit plain pun cipltu which exist in nil analogous cases of e,illl|lii<*t i live 11 v<t<-i-ii j,rp.,llll cal bodies <>, this principle the people 1 tin th •, acting in tlieir sovereign cn parity in convention precisely as lie 1 ml p'e.l their own and lha federal constitutions lmd declared b tin ordi nance i'mi iln 11,'t-i uf congress which li i.i imposed ilutu * llndei the si ' lorirj to im imposts tvere acla not for revenue as intended by the cnnstifutton bti.forpro '"" speech ok ll calholjiv "•<'' iii,l t i'-relti null i„l v„..l the llrliiiiinei thus i'linele.l hv tin p.'op-c l or south cbbbuna ,|„. s..t thcmseltos aciitw fls a stiver 0n the bill further to protii f..r the col ,.;,,„ community was tn all i.n nts mil union of duties on impacts purp st n part nf the institution ofthe cobtinubo.1 btbtoj nn.l though of a peculiar charac . ., ., . 111 r i'-r was us obliaatorv ot tin eiliz-ii of it was thu that i'm rt'iisuiittblt hope f * ,-.,,•., ' . , , ,. , , ,• /• 1 that l-ue us imv portion ot the t n-stitu v f through the election i o-enerd ,,„.„.,:,,,„., „„,,. 1 ah to 1 ,.„,. m.tsl.lased .,.. mill oneo.hcr i « * ., b ,, i.r i that ihb anal disc harge - .„„.. „„ „ alll ,„ „,„., „„.,,,„ o - - public il.-ln i event near al hand [( ( f a * rl „,,, : , r v ,■ remove ottr burden i at e in fc rf m(1 .« „ v ,. rv ,,..„„., « ud leave in ha i r-asury a la sur * m duid rflip j,l ; ; a surplus i1.1t o,.ll„o s ■ xpe d-d . h ,„. o ' r ih'-tnost oxtrava uot » h ui'-s t up , . . .. , ,. ., . 1 ie administered in nil the ulcers i in p priation having the least cole r ol de satea , (| ,, v , 1 „ rlll ( ,„ v „ mm ., ln . „,„. wtw o v',.re.,.st„i.ii,,,„v i hut event a rfeawviiig the harsh mil bill r in i.rrivcil \! the is session ol y.ni , , , . , , -. __,, ii.ivi rs ... = euilliets winch bad lien iiciiih-ii upon 1 s s il was nv wi'il nn ill sides ihat lhe e - - . . , .. , lhan thul nr am i-.ular alii it itjlu pii.uo lebt for all practical purposes „,,„,,,,„„ ,.,.,,,,„,.,. hit t the wa , fact paid the small surplus re profiled in carolina the tn-ii ,.- being nearty covered by the 1 rf r j h . ( , ,., ,,.. „,„-,.,:.,„,„, 1 w . in trn,ts,irv:i,..|ll binds lor l - c „, ur ,. sh , )(> |„„,, s „. ,|„. rt i nntl dun which m already ecru i ; ... individual citiaeus ami hi v..i th arrival ol this v „„ la { . f ft ,„,,„, b v ,,|, ) el..,bm!.sap|„,.„..-d ap f * tau re3u fc h , ha «,.,- , ,,, session of^many uths and unconati.ut.oi.al escroarhmehl thr -.-. incs effort on th par ol theirh „, flnalsland against fsliiii car - hua uud i'n other southern ' . z ,_,,.,, , v „,, , i i „ ,• ii . a . i surnat ion rents «'» with tin-in lint wun s - . ,.. ilnaiii rebel nil that could ta „„. 4 , lfwlli ,,, 1 „ )( . v „ r ,. ,„«,„,„.,, ; „ „| cli.iid wus a anaall reduction i "";, , h:lf su(:fl a .. t of r ,^, stin ., |, v a st.it i.....n e.iunt ., hedu.i.-s but i r.'.lueii..n.ri ,..„ l!m . ieilfl . „ nd „||.., m ee uf llin cit the amount of burden distributed , a , r .. h ,. ll , 1 , n 1 ,,,„ ,„,„,,,. which b , i - 1 more ttneftuauy ttan even tne l j h , r hj i|f ,, ( , nix.-uaiic i8«i i",m,.,.mi..i i-rii.c l)r|ml!i ,, ( , | ll . l „ i „|, lfsw ,. ( . pli , k ,. vc v,.f i '•■;•'' uv l '? ° ' h19 -.'; i y r -.•, bv ., o r l i ht - i i : uties on t h.i tutor heeled than the ' • . , . . „ i i .. " - , . , , untv as has been rcpr ted in debate r-.-u'.l article hy i-oneali-ig a in-ist n /' . . . , .... ., . ". , ns lar aslht knewl.-tl e ol mr (^. exie iis til . i ■ ituties lii.d u.io.i tli t r.iior anil . . . . . , i , ., i . , , , , , not u sin-ile individual bad b'-en removetl im . . .,. - t be biirilun i.i..--1i eiitir iv on hi .., „, " , , ... _ , i ,.-,,. ,., •», . , . • . a r . . 1 be slate had l.l tact acted will the jut j h was thus that instead 1 i.-liel .' n ... , ., .. ,, reat-'st tend-mess nil circu'nslances 1 , an ci ia distiiuiltion ol tl.e - , . , ,. . , , ■,•,,. . considered totsnrds eiliz.-ns who lui i-,l i , l-ns ani tauntitti il tie ooveriiinenl ,. ,, . ,, _ , ..,,..,, _, u i ,. , , . . i i „ iron lh mai iritv ; an.l in inai simit hut «,,, ■ i paymuhl it ihe dob us iiml lieou .. . ,,.,-. , , ,, ,_,, ,, i ,,„ - ' , .' directed the ortth to he itiliin ustei.-.l nil fo , iiiiieti.-.i.t.l the dulie.i weru so ur . ,. . , ,„.,„. , . ,. ... in cases uf some olheial act utiecli-il i • i ra . is t bc in l.ict bounties on one - . . , , , _ , ... . ,, . performed in winch l>'.lielicc tu the ur i,:e and taxitijii on the other uud thus • , , i _ , ijiuauct was involved placing the two real sectums l tin cuuu in ... l,i lict i.i l-f •!••..- toitsfis it hud been urlber objecled that tl cal actio uni 1'ierehv i tun tu that ll.od state bad acted precipitately whal ef political corruption i#1ii.*h thwatons to pr.-cip.tot.lv ! after making a strenuous weep away our constitution an j our lib re istuiic lor t velve ycars-by d,.e„ss,o.i or|v _ ll-n anil in the other house nil on_-res — i'l'iis unequal nn.l unjust a runj in.-nl by essays in nil forms by resolutions rc was pronounced both b ita .« liiinu 1 ia monstrbnees and pr icsth nn tl.e part 1 tton ibroumi its pr pej irfca r in decr ber i.".isl.,:urc 1 finally by bttempling ry of the treasury a - • tl ppo*i •". npp to tv d,e,i,l p.,wer oftbc tin t,"i ) t'.bei.nnvma*.'c-./a.j..-i ent and it dst„is lie said^attempting foi they *»-.- ■;.!., tl i p of rc t .... u.li the md been pr.ve ited fro bringing the oct , i ti".„r„..;.,v,ru i tl t..-st.oti fu.rl before the court and thul eted.andt tnsis so inug apdrel , - -.: at by an act of that lery biajimty in con fc-.il amv.,1 nt which tl.e sttb wba whicl now upbraid then or no *„.,,- lied to cii-...s.b,..i,-i b-..luie uc li'ig that appeal of ibal majonly u,-scentoi.i n ruinous v~t ... of rpres i who .... a notion of o ofthe members ut b ., or a cort to n r ui-rvcd tv".s hw other house iron 8 ( ftrol.-jfl refused powers of which she ulot.e w.is .(..- rigbl l"«fiv loth-faefof ism its true tit o fill judge and wbicb onlv ... tins .,„„... ul that it was a protects and not b revenue uusjuueture could save her she dele "<-•<• th slat lias u-rer .. is 1,-i.e re lut.i 1 on tb alt-r d upon thai tribunal ill si.|,rftmt court the consent of two thirds of ber legma «" vindicate its rcscrv-d n.-bls yet thei tur v.is ssarv for the all luco bnv nl v.i s c...i*lder it an ui.x.l.ut'i vei.tion , ; |, was an..si.ler.-d the only oieaus e •-, f wu.e.i tl.-y am i.,ii rgan ihrough which the p>o «'<«"? u '"'" •*«" hcmselve h its the pl in.li'iis.ver.'i'.n.v culd sp"..k af.u«lslvntlonallt of ct.-n hnd i ter arduous struck he slate rights "<« hee^depr.ve-l of^i txr'.tu of doing so is ii u - l . ,,;,;,, mar lh'o-fb,rl of bj lb l i '''- 1 iv h..i hra s of lb lawislatun lav..rnble solivilbsuiinlii uu ioi>:j d-lay of more to n !' n v io ner i.,,-1,-1 a convert j thati ion years ou«j"r this continued - .. lie was ill-l ih ofliii.iiic iidopled icr.iiu-.hii.ciil f tin j v"t i ncit we ,„,» th c in , niou was nr.-f.lt 1 by a ....;-■ '■ bear ii nil all shli's bv friends and fo ling oimln legislature when tb law to gravely pronuuneed lliui the si.n ft.s est ih or.'ui i iitojixeciiti n wt.re looted uiw.pitalely that i..ei i,.i en.iet.-d ; all 1 which iiml is ii coin nuni j been r.isn ! thai fucti sh ",' i "■ mie in-i cated by be hr*ti lent bad been refer gtijge nfan interested majority who hi xe.f t ibe committee on tho ja '■■•' ary j m-nus ol lus u ...- i-.t.tuii-..iul an.l sppres nd this bill is the result of their labor " isivj system are annuuil smftiiiu mil i < v ar now ,;,. | \| r . i c.rr.-cted ' lions irom tin riontli to be im-t.we.l i.p • . ome t-t the pr n licit nisr-'pre-i-'iitatioiis tier ecu ■».-, was not at all aurpri ii i nature f t ; us oootrvsersy and ' wuatov-r inipe.l«ts the bourse l inric iv i a rapid sk-lch of the n voawnl of and umbjti.ii vvnl ver be menouue-i a ih suit in rcfe-regce to it he iv til-j uoati ni'li sod pre ipii.it i itu.l lial.souil f'ui pr • ..,| t iwiice some b eti ts ontitae hlina deinej b--r r.-slsiaj lif-y in-ieu i ib with il or-linaii aud the pr-tceed i tw-'lv yen -, sl,-t would bnv b-ar-l fr ini under it the sbswb ui.h lbe still 1 ianguaif ; mil i'h first and most prouiin of these is tt was really hui prist igti.tt tb-s h-,nr dir-',i"l against whal is r n,.d the lest i sulfonic in «-** ■'"' tb b«rvlf and wl path whieh an ff.rt bos taao made to buv c,.ii.|-liiii.'"i f hy i u i ftteir gai r»i f-r odiottb s . lar froin dnsernu tl.e vanees vh , bad pr..i"un,:,'il lb v-rt h is d-,,i-i.-i;.ti >., wbicb bus fienn l-v-lb which sh ba i hem rt,d willnu her l.n.i.s mi i.e it ho vi-w-d t'.ns pr.-i-si -„ i tb t-i be opprefsive uui-.-n-titutioual " •'' t ■" - as 1 the murul result of ih ram us aft t n i'uhj « slnyula — ■ j '-■ ii.-ri l hy the slat and the jjle e ■.-.- r than that brhicli pn |, ••' ■ ', • .. riipi f :-• p.-opl sepanttioo of these ststwt t'rotn the nt . r m _*-"' tmmm ui-ll luk i olxhi m 8 | suuuh iltu/jcf ul uni fwiusi vf l_»v /'-. il tiojaii war le-ulal ii tv ,* il,iiu i . ■ i tt^^^^^^^^mn^r'amiw r.|.il.i.ic ! ! no it is uot carolina which i adopted i force ti.e ribui e i if course has soled pi ', i„!-ly bin b.-r - - i i 0 mosl d.-rl-ivn . iima-i-i . 8ta.es who have su i tu m ..- n - .:,,..;, ■•,,, i set is halves iter ihu iinv n.i 1 n ip i i ((,,-- y-i fn irt i .. ll.u , , i v-nhi , the i i is acted us sh hpsdoh — i.n i ti ,., rm y i,.uiieod.,tn'tl i 1 ... bib reported tb ober ed th.-ir duty with equal e,.iergy and riihvby uifh.flr foren tbo cjvd lilhunals proi pi.i nttr situat.nu this day w.ajl-1 snd civil pi ■-,.-. s 6f tne til ! i . ui.l he ven thif j ,-: i mu what we now i'm i tl .<'., i e .,.,,, r in lull . . .. i i i >. - it 1 it delays aro s:.nl in in dun r .... nud mouts w ucb hun 1 . m ■ 1 ,,,, i n p „, r never was he muxtin more true ihm in in its support nsthe m&fl irumipha ac lhe pre 111 e 1 — ., •■ 1 of 11 n-.p-dv ii i.iiowl . 11 il lli.it nnlliri i,t ,. n is peace is t'i v i '. .•', 1 n 1.1 ,. 1 lies :., ;,.... |',|| i ,.,;,, . t ; un i ... i • i-i , till retlcln if wu take from u -, ! -, i ,,...-- ni-.-i of 1 m m p nipl s 1 111 — etu that il in pr ..-■■!■ if lis lull 1 ill i li 11 in lb ■ anil a ik a--.,il 1 i in n pi i1.1i1 ig lh ■ olh.-r the sidf fr.a.t wlncb w ittttt must ( '.•._*.. ni . 11 .! subsli.ihipg 1 np.-ein i-..iisiu.iils kvay and 1 i 1 . whitb ». icy ifthe lawn i.i act,tli . , i btvo 111 1 1 ■ ' ', a . i in r ■ ._.-. mitch is lh h.ll i.-l'ul 1i1-1 11 , , 1 . :-. ph a 1 1 nei , i 1 1 pr 1 ■•. nv 1 i mi || left us thut tllfl r i •■ 1 11 mu x ,,''- i'r 11 iii ' s i 1 1 ' t r • ■ ■ |. '. 1 ,., ,| i i n |, hut iilvaei lhe cults i ull ill of jh pr steed of its industry ..,,,• 1 ■ s n-'i carolina ir-u b,-l n i b tows up 1 the i , s.'ctl ii .,. lhl ill ■ ■ i-i in n i|,,.-i ,-. 11 h ur.l u ll it i i f fh-il - 1 . ni il 1 tni -, 1,1.1 , >|. 1 ne ■ t 1 1 ii rlty which 11 . ihoiis , 1 a in 11 ... i 1 0 ui — , ■ df - s 1 ,, 11.1-11111-1 11 11-1 1 tliii sl . tt-il us ihat prnvemeiit of rivera and liurlx - 1...1 1 1 .• tsupie .<■ niiisiii pp 1 ... 1 11 . uul taiiuls nn.l 111 cum a liiipe lliat . it • , ter p all tlir v-is|es be.w.-f.i 11 - n in p'liinlv can devise an wt then ta and ii » (• nural iovrn unrnl wily u',,iisi,l llinl tint pn pie lif monopoly i '."., 1 ■ i a ,, 1 leavo lin 1 . t . . : rows ivi,"]i 11 i o inipk remunerated at tuui tribunal t ivuy i m-i uni . iiide the cxpt-nae nfthoae who support it 1 fcnd to them tli ... ■ .,,,., 1 i . ,,, . ,,.,-. this 1 the real rea.on if ths i'uct which and lh in made 111 pursuance ofif tu.l w wiiii-ss thut all acts for pro , nou tne assert 1 , i 1 ..-• ,.. \ „ ,., ', tss w ib -, ,, ill iii.n.ri.i-s ut - n 1 c ,::•■• tbey cl-.i 1 : . 1 --• irfws it tol i-.i.i:.i ii in 1 uud i over fl sii.it st 1 is p i i lo resist no pro ivhclmihi majorities i . j who seek ideas of tho e.iurt '•'• h lire run r 11 lb ui 1'iopoly , cn l-nvor tn obtain it iu the ti.e pr-sideiit tl.o 0x1 i.sivt iiid 11 iii nil tl mosl vclu--ivc btipe ; and lii-v ink ear srtvors provided 1fi ibis lull i x ,,. ni accordingly to a <- elate only a sdfficinut li.iribe linn tu u - n lai i ri - tour number nf interests barely to puss it i the civil pr is i the si i • ' l_,u thr-n-h tiie two bnuscn f l on^rcss — on ■!*<- answer can be tv.-n to it in 1 the plain principle that tli r-ut-r th tiniest between the tuie in i 1 . ■ pnit-r nu nner from wh n ihe monopoly lakes ,! government ifthe reslstatao bo iiuit.-i and tu 1'ivcr on vv li nn it bajtow tint 111 b-itli sid-s to the civil process ' i ■ greater is the advantage lo the innnopo hut ■*. by its iohareut - vur ignlj , t m i li-t aetiti in tbis spirit we havu oft-ii n-r.ip.'ii its reserved powers will pro seen with what exact precision ihey c.iint popowerfol in socna u-mirofssi \ i and adding wool to woollens bssoe.st.ng lead bust triuuinb over the federal ii verp and iron loiding tbeir way uiiiil u bare pent sunt lined bj its dele|pitqd and linii majority i obtained when tta bill paaaay ud authority ; und in ms answer we cfanneettng just us many ititcr';sts us i ntvc au ackt.owl ignieni of'th trull ol suffisient to < u-itrc its success ainl no kuso great principles fur which tta slut m , re lu a short time however wu las so lin ily uud nobly cniil ol,-d uav iiivariablv und bat tins lean ta having made these remarks tb tent comes 8 deeided majority tinder the cer idestiun is now presentcl : has foil .. - tain operation which compels individuals hu right to pass this bill i which hu to desert thc pursuits whicli the monopoly would next prottet',1 to coiisiuer th .)■• bnv rendered unprofitalne that they may citiolrpf this question involves ihe n pint participate in those pursuits which it bad into lbe provisions of lbe lull what a e . id . rod prolimihi it is u_-.ii._st line tbey r ll pulaat vi lis;».sal 01 tun i'i s •,,.. dangerous und growing disease which tl army and navy , uni the entire militia of south cnrilfiia has acted a tlisouse the country — lt enables him at his plou whose cunccrous iic.ln.ii would sootl spread > ire to subject everv 1,1.111 in th united to every part of thu system hud it not states not exempt fiom imliiia duty to been speedily ayfested martial few — to cull inm from ins oadimt there wa another powerful reason wliy rv ucciipati'n to ita fi 11 and under thr lb bclinti a-i'tli sl te ni i out bl safely p'i.allv ol ti ie an i i'upi isniuneiit inlli-li-l delayed the public debt us be aad ui by a court martial t rtabrue in baud in ready staled for all practical parpoees lus brothers blood tin-re is no limits bul already been paid and un.ler tta tion qilthe power of the sword und that existing duties a largo annual surplus of v-r the puis is equally without restraint many mill una 11111-1 comfl liiu in tr-a for am 011 the exiia-.nl.iinrv fixtures i miry ll v is iini-o--i!-le to look ut this th bill ll c,,,ta isil'.uppi.ipii.ili 11 which tut of ihin-s without seotpg the nee under existing cirruii.nlances is tanta mischievous c..n-"q.i ucs umi aiien.g uount to mill nited appropriation th ulhers it not sp-oduv currcctud it wouhl president may under it uuiliinty incur 1 iierp-.se powerful und almost insuperable ahyexpendilure and pledge the natioiial obstacles in browing ih'lbe burden under liutli to n t 11 lie may croat a in which the south had been so i iug laboring nstiynal del.t at ihe very inunient of lhe rhe disposition of the surplus w u.i be termination of the firmer — a debt of mil come a subject of violent und cuin.pt ikuts t ta paid out ot sine proceeds t the struggle and could not foil lu rear up new labor oftbal section oftho country it i v-i and powerful uilere-ts in support of th dourest < oiisuiulionnl riylils this hill . xi-ting system nut only it those see protstiulos thus exhibiting the eltrai.r li 11 winch hnve boeo beret fore benefit linsrv spectacle that the vory scelioi led hy it but even 111 lbe south ilsclf he of ibe couotty which is urgiu-f ibis ui ■ oul i not hut trace to tbo anticipation of urn and carrying tho sword qf l-vu-in t 1 iul of tb treasury tl.e midden and tion against us are bt the am time in ext a rlintirv movements which bad take currmg n m-w debt lobe paid hy tfios place al the last session in tbe virginia whose rights are vi,,lit-,l wlulo those legislature in winch the whole south who violate ibem tire to recoive ihe le'tie was vitally intere-t.'d it wus impossibfe lils in the sbupo of bounties and expeu.li lor unv rational man to believe tbat that lures still 1 c.-uld seriously bat thought of ef and for what purpose is thu vllimitcl li'i'ting the sfh-ini to which he alluded eoptrol of the purfe and of the sw.ir.l inns by bur-owt resources wilbou powsil'ul pfocetfut the dis|_os..ion of the kx.-ruti aid from the general (. i-iuiiici.t i make w.ir agains om i the froe , , i 1 was uitxi objected ihat tta enforcing s.,v-r 1 01 fneatbers of this e nl'-d.-niliou ; ui have legislated th united slates out which ihe bill pmp s.ts 1 deal w.ih i .. of south faioluih lie bud already re 11 statu , ul is a coll-'ti i haudll.i or pu d to ihisohj-.-timi oiiiui'itli-.t ixiciisiuii outlaws thu viobiliu un impi-u uud would now but repeat what be then spectacle f.fllus i t-rmnt-it ino er-aiii smd—that tb-y bad taen legislated out ■,! the stau-s making r aguinsl ibu p.'iiv nly t . the 1 xlu'nt ; that tbey bad no n.lit er i , whieh it owes its existence 1 , . ujcr tbo con-tit im 11 in i odinill d p e |„|| • i.lat lhe conbiifkli -., plain il.e junstlku ul'hie united st..t-s willi | v ,,,|,.| palpably in many i'lis prousions 1 . lin liufltsfofluft vv-'ral ital ally -" , v atilh riiiiog lbe i'r-si-l-ul at ills pl-u liir us fbc 1-1 v ui i power aulhucht-id ; iup to p,in»i ita dlflfcnmt p"i is of tin ne.,..id thnt thev wro intruders und l'un.u n uu uni-'pial fi.dtmg . ntrary i iii^ht ritilitl'ullv lei expelled : and thai tnat provision uf ' t i n-iiiiiii-.u which hey had > ■— 1 lli'i-nily ei-'-ll'-f bv low decluru thai 1.0 prof roboe sl-aildb v-u i i,l uio.».*f lb stnie tin 11 _". her fivil ,,, ,„„. 1 ,, v r a ih-r it fibiu violates p , • --, a ha bv-n a ix 1 vl".l,'".l in ml ,|,„ 1 ,' „, i.ui.jii hy u t •■ ■». ■___; hll.i .' , i ,,.|,|.' inflate is iv a " ■ hr-ii i | 1w diserf 1 ,.., to iiii.o-m cm duties in ., i .'■ tn-i'i i tho i ict 1 ine r whicli the , nv . v„l wlnl-er iii is all iwo i in ulnar n..j ir , , i , hua bad contended by nuabhug he i i "... to r-'.i.ilato 0010 fh vers p i'-t ul is-u b-twe . tbetw . li :. p v r v in ch'iji -- lioi , uii.s thrsb was wui.ir uullific tti-.u and v i vtt-ij wubi'i in jur.sdjc.lon < if 11 pencil ■' ' 1 edl nt m iv a the ij-iile-l slates ,■..... i p.w.iri i'i '. - - l,n iul un ' ' lilu-i il ..<•! if tb gen tci'l i i be o ml-rr"il .... ll.eiu as or.-u ,..„! ii ..-,"■,.,. ot »;', winch . night is a asm hj.-u ,;,- wero tb y tachu|d m t i s such mr hi ... ui stile t r..l i_"nli un 1 1 hu pr wsiom 1.1 hill which it an parti-s a . ital he aots against i.t a siuglu bl .*,— l.y treatitag t(i states ai ,,.-,. it ia hr 1 d ar i_it.-.,-i»lillltl ill su in so i.iwles mas if individuals ., . i , p.-ssive tim e.c..r-.v«rsv was n pro-lr all ih bainor ol the ' oiih.i.u ,,,„,, , • ,, 1 is v win ir iiiz s ;, 1 ' in w.-.n i puss nv-r lb minor cu .„,.,,,, ,,. 1 i 1 m.nsi t'i n-:k 1 > tl i-i'l-rulions m.'l proceed diroftlv l-.tli ',,„', ,.,. ill-its 4 i ■ n ii . i'uslrat p-ii.t this hill proceeds until ,,. i..l ismw ie x ... ita ir ! r 11 1 tout nv emir v i-i-titv ef tbi ,..•..■ .„,,.. x ;.: al r lielouus to lie ,\ ui it.i pe-.pl itviiid aa tthmw yioiei;'w»ol tuu luaius ,** luffing ouu j^tct aou>iuuui^^ujj . n,.t\v,lb-lai.,ltii nil i ial ' . i i he must say that net ther the 8c ■• • n i delaware mr clayton nor am mliev ii .... hi -| la oi the kino s.'i r botlt nn.l nirli met be groat quest ii ub i issutti i this b l-'-ilerul union 7 a ii f ' states iis distinct ii'.-iii ibal of indivi ualsfi is the sovereignty in the sbveruffs ■ r in lbe a in a i nu people in the u . . ■ j ti vi it language which we n i 1 li 1 in us ■-, when i aki _■ nf u political institutions affords proof coneluaiv its its real cbaraciar tho terms mu ., i d era i unitod all imply u ci mhii uh i tt ~ i-r.-iyii.ies a coiif , i rnl n oi f sun ---■ the are never applied lo an naaocinli-m of individuals who ter bear of l united inic . f ne v,,,k of uassaebi sctts or ol virjiniu ' who ever honrtl lha leim i'd ral or i'n on applied lo tha tb aggregation of individuals into uw cniiiniiiuity .' n.r is the other point l-s clear — but lbe sovereignty is iu the i-i v cral states nn.l lhal ur system is u ur_k ion of twenty four sovereign powers u let u ,'— iitiiiioiial eoiii|.nct i,,,l not of a d.vr il,-,l ovht-eiiiiily bet-seen the slides st mr illy iu i.i lbe united slut 3 in pile t all thul bud b--u saitl hu iiii.iiitiiiui'd tbat spvereigntl is in its nnliitr in.iiiisibl m it is iii siipiciii po.ver in ii state an i ws ui,;lit ju-i as well . peak of ball a aqasrck r hull i tit-mgle us f hull u soyureigob i . i ia a gross error to confound ii east errist of sovoreigu powers iiith sxrerri ',* ly itself - or lhe delegation of such powo willi u surrender ol ll al \ hoverrigu may delegate his"jiowers.t be -\. ii scd by us ninny a^culs ., ■ bs inn ll i 1 proper under such c iiioiia uti.l willi ii ii liuiilati ns us be in im p.sc , but to sui reiidilr any poili ii uf i_s mirigiui to sii'tlioi is tn iii.iiti.ilai lit llllole 1 lie s illtor froll d 1,1 ml i v i|v i lay :,..,} calls ii in uhtiipl si.cul ic mnjh ivui'h ii ny s he uiiui'.l conipi '-.-._. ll by in-lapiiysics bo elms ihui -■ - m ii iiii in ut whioh i hikes ui-'i j n i.a without iilf r.iii'e no one enn hoi il iw thr wester v carolinl 1 v it _, „, ,, / once a week nt two dollars per fi , i if paid in'hi i three montht or two i . i l fifty ota's if po ' . • •-./ oth f , ,., in ihr ,,, tr vo pn i r trill fu /.„■ i'r,:n i irti'l all arrearage arc „,, ,' , -. ul it editor 1 * discretion — v ri , t i,7 be rtceitedfof a ut t:n ' o year t e to notify the editor of a tcish to .' ■ i • , iiin ir it m i uli before the expira tin t ,,," il year trill lir roiindt rid as a fter .' i t an person irocurinir six solvent suh icrihcrs to ih carolinian shall hatt a rr , rii paper gratis — kdvurtising a the f)sii ' il '-• • ettert addressed to the editor mutt tc ii " mil or they will not be attended o j i m terms will be strictly adtier ed i ,- rard th st -- rs mere i lions r c nn i lies and ict n in i nil nil pait i t'i i'n 1 ton ; linvill ii iii ne right t i l-l the n ■ h •!..» ot tbo v<!|,|i,l-l.t th county i a ... resist tbo authority nfaj state and irnatjna such t i-i„,,ce as the !.,«!. as arts of so inant individuals with out possohsiug s iterci-niy r political ii._h li in 1,—n said l.iui lha bill do lures war ngain.t south carolina nn it 1 cn a uiu-,-,11 ",'.-., fin r , ii ll i >- ur lots so il r ci bling nl ui it in.l it uh all it li..rr,rs bring inlh action the high • ■-- qualities i,i.iiii".-iii,ii and mural it iin p.-rlinps i ti 1 r ..." i'n vi i in that il li ni i i per miunl i-i ilia i"i piitp.'se uul bis lull 1-el nc ,," war e\.v 1 . . i cil il be ih.t is inch sbwogos iv i ■. — i war nol biniiusl tta oi iiiiiiuiuiy il iht eiii us ..' '. .... ill i c.iiiiiiiiniiy i ,- . i . i it il in ti'ilcd it us worse ihmi a/.-ir ... .. i ri — a nil ultempt iti i ike nivuv ilf lol tlie color i law ivitll ill lhel l.l 1 li | i rill.y oilier site ua i . im n in i ' ib-niiiioii lias thrown around ih life : lb i/,.i ii authuria -■* lhe i . ,- , foi i ii lus deputies when lliey muv su ie law t . ta viulut.'d w.ili i i • i i ill i'a 0>>urt or jury , to kill mi i ii iii-r v oi discrimination li iv , s«id in th s.n.ii r iron teniief :..■.( i -. uudy '•• he a iii>'«iiiire i ,. '. p -...■ , n . tta wolf give lbe kite io ii l..vo i such • ; i . 1 1 i,-m 1 1 f iiml ; or de.iil lo its in ii ! v peace b laiiuguishiug llu p i^i.tiie af i in st.ii , ui aw mg || i .,,, union ,, t >( ihe txpt cts ill ',' wll e'i -' oust iul s but i a ■ . , , . i in uu li i - to s car ditis | i i ,, of s-lf pr-'s-o v it l.m iiii-l i pi in ii ii ihat s vint i iln lull piss and in if i .< lut in ii i ■ enforce it it will ta it |. |,| i ■ , . i zir ! — even thul , i death it ll i il . m i t'i i btt'si ca luii.itx : then .. :,' - tih iii ,' •• lei ribr io lh frtlh u'1,1 brut i • ".' n pf-lf lhi in i',ii . i pfbcod lit ios f l,b-i tv 1,1 i ilol or there are tb u*mntla of h r b,-.,v ms nil il'i 1 !>•", nrc prepared chi c i'n ... lav down fb-ir lives in defrifce • th slut l lliu great pnueiplcs f con iiiiiiiouul liberty for wbicb be is contend ing u,.l i'orbtd but tins should b"c-.in no ary ll n«v can i.i lulcs.s in , uovernment is resolved ... bring be ques li it lo extremity when i.-r gallant son will stand pn pared to perform tin lust hi iv ; i . lie nobly i t said ilr iilhoc.ii on ibo ground i li.ii mis ci institution was made bi t!i l.ilcs ; thnt it is u i'-l-rnl u lion uf tl.e sinn s iu which t.i s — 1 st i.e slill re iu,n the.r stivereig ty ll tlieao views he correct he baj i i ,- ui.i,-i n7 he lull io sir nitiiy , w lich presents the question ivb-thcr 1 li v le or b n 1 lie would not ent ir nit tin discimsu.n oft mat question now ii would rest it for the prn-ent i wliii if ha-l id on li introduction -.. i re , inl n now on tho tithl uii.l-.r u li p that another pp rtu.iity would be if : in.l l',r iiior uii.pl discos-mii ||.. would for the presenl < fiuc lus reiuiili in the object i ns winch had im en raised t . the view which hu bud presented wlu.ii he introduced ibem ibo uull.or.ty i luther li.rt.n bud been adduced l.y tl.o -, iiator from i b.wurt in prove lb.it tl.e , iliz-nh f it slut bchnr under tli nil ilu.ri.y a u stat w-re liable iota pin ism nl us ti lit it by this i ivirii.ii ni a iniueyt «# mr l.irtiu was as a wy in.l ns lii"ii is in nuiliorilv might bo cut u r i ii ;. e nl p ml in could n-l sj cppl it iii di)|6r>uiiiiug tin puint at isaui the : iiituu.li which i.e , ii j li tali n in new wo.ii i l.iss-ii il u i destroy lib weight ol'lns authority lie had b .. *..-. lei.tlt opposed in nv un ii lu the . ' un st i miaou i.iij tlm v , i let i r from wtticl in tie t,-r l.-is ip...l tl w.u tu ten ie i ... s-ua.lf msrvluiid lolli ... utloplion — wilh this view it yti to be xy . le ' thai ev-ty . i-.,|.-i.-,t ii . ileuli.feil t.i-.fii'ci unit ■ bj - ■ should is urged : that real obj fti-uis iluul i he x li p'lulod.b ''"" bb having ,, . |. iiiii.ili hi except ui re plau-ible d 1,1,'ii n hould hi pi j-iii-.i ll is to ii n irii timt in attribuu.il ihu pint ,, i fr la r.in in rcp'rniie lu i lie p ml unil-i . , i-nl,i.ri i ih.t if l.is mill atttj i •'..> u i.rn sui.tt it iiii-i li admitted i , ta qual'v ... ii i.u-.l'.i ;. ll ,,,- i.piflion i tli . nt li prot ihu a cizap ol'lb.t tstnui ,, l punished xt u trail r wl u.ii..j uud t alli-g.ttiii.i to ih ti it is also i i . lx givou i fb cu .,-',. ii n i-t •,"• p..-t . ti ni i'uibii il o-.tiie l.v ihe --,. .-, 1 tl ix ri.u.-i.i i.i.l lhal lhe provisions in iu constitution bgi'.ilitliug ii still - to l h.i i lip i hull willi iii cms it ol ' on -•, was u.li mi led lu n rv i right ..; pr li . i i i , hie tit ii'-s ihouistilvi and i.i it i.n stale should protect its own ut uiti,'i"iii i show i i ii , authority wa m ii.-i.y a--111..1111 in opinio to ik <>. | unl hi.t :. rily ou both points i m t-ui i tnirrussilig would be lie atlitude in wb.eli 1 w lll.l plnee the senator i'imiii h-i.wai roo^irt.'r-'oiitbiii|)i tlniii h mr i a but if on i.n coiiiruiy in i loans lh ,. ■># er ul mill lysis and cuibiinilioii in.-.i w t*r winch reduces the iimst . .. pi \ 1,-a into u cl.-itn.-nis which traces ,■ u to their first principle and in iht p .- r of -- l„'llll|.-.|lt--ll llllal .' ull 1 1 ill 11 iii ' i • ill it ill 01..1 ll.ll iliniuotis sy oi . , h/tm tar from di-scrvtiik cuiilcippl '' ••- ' ' ' *.•'■» ami ,... ill lit ol lh bu an l.,,,i . .;. i power which raises man above in in he — which ili.litigi.i_.lii bis ti.tul.ifea li nn in ro sagacity which ho i ids iw c..111..1.11 with inferior annuals li ,,■ hits power whi.ih has raised tin i-i:nii.iniui in in l-oit.^r a mere gazer n the sin is io tbe high ii.lcllc.cliud cuiin-i r of u new ou or lapluct ; mid u<lr..tioiny itself front u mure ol.m-rvul.oii of insulated in is i.,ii ihat ble science whicli displays to ns uilinirniioti the system of ii universe a shall ibis high ponei of the mind w inch i is ifi te,l such w.tt.d'irs when hi r.i l.il to ll laws which control tint ,,,... tcrij.l world is lurevor prohibited under a n hhhii'ss cry of iii-lupliy-i.'sl i'n in bt ing iippucl to tlm lugh purpose i political so knee itinl aywiiti,„i 111 beld tliein i . !><» m.l-jncl to luws as iii i us ulullnr itself n.i to bu aslil a suiiji-t'.l fur lbe applica tion of the high at ml ll ctiinl p i-r 1 lluik-lutl-.il iii v iii ll.ed full up lil lh inn pin tlciiiplirtir l it inur tir>l prim pi ... it lb u;..,ti liailli ani ll.,i-9ii ' hi t i i sl uolbl.lt i i.e gr ut „,*.-. y in w.i •■ buy i.i.ii...r<.iliz 1 ihiije ii.iiii i l.i.|iiie tiin w,il t om wti.ii nulls will pe-v-iil tu spile t pu piiii . and i iioii,'iall.it ; m.d wl.i',1 p i.t ml i'lpb i li i iv.ii hn ctj.ij.ids .- d a n ... u set am ,• ... asuro'iiutny umi cht-i,.:st i in nneximi n.lb ihi jun i th tib f t in uil.l ik'.h hi :-. niiloi ii in v'ir j?iu.u ( dr iiivbs i ni in i .. ■ x.a iy ... c oiv.ill-,1 i n.i ihat aporli.iti remain cd will tlm mates s.'1-ti i i-,,,i ih residue wns ie-l"d in lu i in j fly l.'oi.ii i iip;-ik,,l iiml hi st-iiiitor in ut tne i n.ted status it a li be lus ui-bo lil u — if h iiil,-nib-i in mil in in lbs soicr.-.i y w in tb twt-niy im hiatus iii whatever li„-ht im uui'lll vi w m ll.oir pini ms wi ul i ii i .':'..'•; but bc ling lo his ( dr (,'-..) cn epli iii th w lite over ,;- ily wus in ihc -••./• ral stales whit tin x",..-e f vt'c|j ■ ra was div.d u i par ta rx r • •..->■. i iiii.l.-r compact through t in l_-ri-r .. i i'.v.-.ii nt umi tl.e m me i ti.li .!,- s*|s,rii.ii alale i t rn tu i.t hui if diasii-iyr f|,.iu virginia mi k.w n-mii io us.,-11 that tli twenty lour i mtnle formed l,ul ,,.,- cauhiinmiiy with 4 l 11 . ; i sliv 4,-1 p ii r ix to th 1 ' t 1 ' ... it hui ,., it tv.nil-l l but tbii ,. viva m i of it 1 i lt 11 f h '' i.'l-r lhe i'll 1 m i wh a u ....... inilwcen talcs as ilistn.rs fl i mini ul mi or a ui'io nu-r mil ..| ma fl i a-iierii-an p iple is 11 mass ol 1 li il....!,,l lu i ill till ll.;lll hlb opinio s would itiojb 1)1.1 ■ - '.■ 1 ' ■ i ti^^^^^^^^^^^^m onil lliiis wilh whom n is ii.iti.i — thut ni l > r.-tiiri t tbe bill it is - i lii.il the sw.rd uud the bayonet to en that in - bill uugbl to pas because i ,■» i ri*e he eseeuti •!. il'ui uu'-..ii-uii.ii...iiil w 0.11 rt ta ... forced i'i law must ..* act it i'onuress he nil i spreis ins af ciif.ucad the imperial edic u ■•-! im riae lliitt the slightest uth ail l.l favor prut i ll is tuel r suljil s,,p . ry f power should ty r ved as the itiosl ,- u hud in t-ourtol tenns without balking couclu-ive ■ vi i.t ..',«, wllil.t ibal wbu-h ■ i 1 : ... ii.n-i , ■■,, * i cl .. u i x i at l.-a.t ■ pially air.'r hi li i 1 , ,- f p , , :..» md liberty ts wuvil a*_,t si iij i -,' ■ . . , is t .« vuil jtlvuis bsjv*i**s il wsa a j h>ji*u«t.v *+