western r#i f j /**/** £ %/£* g i£/hlaizfo §&■ o it is v wise to abstain from law which jiowever wise and good in thi nsalves have the w nblanco of inequality which li-i i no r-.|iiii-:e in the heart f theeitiaon and which will h evaded wilh liti remorse the ■ i i rn i i i i especially snen frt grafting laws on conscience dr vhnnnsng hv burton craige salisbury rowan cop i ', v c ... -. > |> \\ i vn-uvry it 18 59 vol ' iii v .' ties de tha engrossed i..1i loprovide for the inm prompt adminutrnti m l justice in the counties of but kn buncombe lincoln and rutherford were ren i the ibird time passsid i,i,l order i to in ull iti mr t . in r from the joiul i.e com mi too i wh an vv i ri red the letter t in juverftor of ino state i's uth caro ni,i i the governdr oft liis state i igoth r with i ," ace panying d.m-uinents . onipani .: tho following ■ ".' 1 ns : stock nut nf the whnlo amount of thu joinf ; ■ !- ••_••'.■ i i , lhal government tbe power act is revolutionai*y andthe former unt\*^h capital stock nf said bank faring war of mgulitiinji con rco i'bnj sre both acts nfthe same soverei h mr spin iii | ited a hill to amend , ining in dies with forei n nations power and exerted lor thn iii eurn an act passed in ths year 1 bus tn provide sn.i ol doing other bc.s of sn external the violent nets ,.| a n 1 throwing lfl t'..r a li ,->,,,, ,,!',, "..",.-, iui'l ta chsll ll i r itlii.-h i ..... 1 eiiiia i i.r note ii lawful r li iiiit lipm tle-ir i"..i,lii,*.,^h ir dohflnn a huppiheas uid interest nl ull lie nii-us violating the constitution ai h bill i i thn net to ve.l ihe ,, i,i nf ml pnwei not grunted lo thi general gn forms of government are revolutionary u,h elerti count ami 9u vernmont is reserved to lho state ros ihrirchurac.ter nnd wnuld t i to a dim h pcrior courts in ths )• white man of pt-etivt-ly or tn the people bn inng us lution of the union but will any ,,,.,, h thoir n octivo i ; tho tit t nf thn genqrul antl slat government keep lin bus u.y definite idi i l tin t nm ln-h rend lit i lime arid ivi.hiu thoir respective jurisdiction sti uses call tha revi.lutinnury wlii it i i-h lh nd i tever.il times passed and long will tlm cnnsti.ti.in.i as nll as tin nined by a people in thoir higln t aovor i nl,-i -! i - i . i...i •. i i liberties of thu citizeus bn pro eign capacity and carried into i,,,-n,",lh on i dr il.n the 9 rod hut -,. , ni either transcends eflhcl by their courts and juries \.., it ,-■ to tnlio up the hill to reduce tin it prescribed limits t li.it syiouionl the preposterous to j » .-. > t . - ■ ■ i !.-•■ that revolutio - h of the supr court judges n.nstitn i is violated und tha butter ary which i ml d i i a ■-. l-ii . lui-h^h which was rend tho second time and pa ,, ,-. ., right to immediate redres is penc rtl in iti cl inntcr nml iv.-.-.iti-il^h d — vyi ::'- sloes 10 hesn dill.cul.k and conllie between the ,<:,•.., * to tin i .. ..: , f l.-.w ll il h . bailoy , . '■- half of himself an,l ths sneral government as the agent and the nnl 1 " ■ iti-ni is not h lohilionnrv it '• i,i,,ritv..l :!„•,' ,, in s to nwpectivii slate as the principals were t-ilit a-it i eive.l it ha i '■ lina documenls presented the f.r -■, ihe puinots and igas i much ions is it unlive rsivn nf thi>h cmintoi report ; which u motion ol hi constitution tjiero were two constitution or does it tend to a 1 lu ■ moiitgoniery of hertford was laid upon j""*tii in f earenow i ion ofthe union ifthe btates wore "-- ■ the tnhln und ordered xn be printed i '•' will lie ao lung as this gov creigripowt when tin compact was en ■ thcjoinl scleel i mittee to whom ' ■«■ ■ '"•""• '■'""'" '""'" » tcred into end hav i parteo with thath waa referred certa ocu nts transmi ''^ tierol government n 5 sivorcignly ftlwy have the right to judged ledby hisexcollencvtheg vorne ofs ' « i reducing the sui.es to pel when that compac has been broke nmh i carolina to the governor of hi state ui'l '' ' ' «■.« i "" "<""' »"'' '"'"■". ''' ' ' v '' v "' w p rop " rtj h i l.s h,i i nunie li.,,l legislature '• " l " th as tl.e champions of e l.ltert.es and hvnenf their .-, s „-■ i hav ade their repori nnd have recoin "' ;'* '•' ! " ' -""'-•' rial liberty the has been demons rated the cona.it ■ i mended certain resolutions tho under •'''■*' '■'"■<■■■ ; ' "•'"-"■ wh.lated gov teadof b g auhvereii will bo j.reseryed isig is one of hat mittee begs ■■;■ '■»' " '■' jth much pertinacity and the union our glorious i i i , ■ i i.-..v ... submit the following re«soi i zeal that right m ilec.de a con transmitted to posterity a 1 precious hen ■ i wherefore he could not assenl ... '-<.'- this versy between a sunn and tj j..i.,i ... tagewortl.y ofthe son of freedom i i principles contained in thai report tho t of tho states sh , i be lodged ... thn i he efforts which the cit.zen*ol -";■ i report asserts thst nullification is rcvolu u »■" the the departments of the gon carnl.naare v making for political an i ,- 1 riil tsnvertin.etil \ dialincl nronnsition em lihitv are v,,rlliy ulili s,.,i , l^b ■ 1 in in its character subversive ol tl "- »»""" u >• iintuci iu .,,-,..,.,. ■ 1 1 1 1 . i mis um <■ 10 in the u.nvrri the unrein those levi utinnarv hemes who sacriiici >■ ■ tiiiiti.iu and lends 1 u dissolution l """'"■ " •" i ' "- "»• u|ireiin i the union if ihis were in rl it .-.,- •' " r - these efforts foiled because the their lives i.r thc rights ol man ■ ■ 1,1.1 it thia were true tint it itel>ltblh'\n6 of that dav heliev the tariff acts ol whjch thoy compjam.b ■ s.-,-,l ether of these permcioiih qualities ' ' *-. . • 1 ... h ■ , ' ' ilia it w.i.i he untv se l 1,11st i.nt wo ourselves iir..ii,,nii i,,,-.,,'sliiiiii,,ii.il,^b ■ it cortn.lllt merit the severest disapiiro uinni it yyouio oe untvisi 10 1,111 auj 1 h ■ ,. •• 1 . i nt i iih iii ii ■- it i 111 i ■ u i ai thai oppressive untl unequal lu 1 -..'-*, in :<■ ■ l.iii.oii nnn cen.suro from everv iru-nu 1 * - ' '->•'-. "■" » 11 .... r .... 1 i ■ , , ,, ,,,- i ,,, ,, "... inii a il 11 ur a in iii i ::, i.".o,i i in -, , l . a . i.l.'.l ' \ i ' m ■ the constitution and ti the union but it v '> " "'> ""- " " , o ul "> 01 " ,( " usu.p.i g 1 ■ i i'mi.im-y i sl l.l he ..,„■, 1 ie lol l-gi-l i ni.r.l i in.l.n 1 |..,|..« ■ i i car iti and 1 h atari oxa.n ion tn the journ il oftho venlfon nul the "'-' pp n .°" "" l'™«.ed to wit 1 it ■ ■ , , . , ... 11 . 1 1 . 1 . -... - •" nee ei i lha i ongress have th ,'.-,,' h ■ t,.,-,-'-s the only conservative pnncipe h constitution will show that no such tribn ■. ■ ■ whichthecmstituti tan be saved i aal wa ever made from the fon-oing p to lay imposts but it ia nwntanedh i the 1 ,„,■„,, .. l tl „ sl , orvations.it would seem to follow aan "'» " 1 "' ™' ™ f a j 0 ' n "° r l ■ advocates am he friends of sluts leiili.nato c tlusion '• that the several nd reven toe,and thai eve l ■ ■ rights and ennst^uiiona li y - siatc igthe uni^d statesof a »;■;■ ' z i ■ dertoarriveatucurreel a.id -,., i 1 ■- a n , re 0 u.med o the pr.nc pie of « struggling hgainst acm ■ ond , uponfh..ali 1 „,,.,;,„. and b uuluni.ed maanon to in genera gov ■ ,, ur .,,. w h zz iz unc^um ■ sorbing question it is necessary in ea.t.n er,,n,enu but that by compic under to « ■ ■ ine wul the fouudut bns up 1 which 0111 i.yle and till a constitution for the u , • n ,,; ,, 1 r.r ... h itrovernment rests and esi v fhe ' ed s s and anusndnieuts thereto they "' '""-"' : '' "' "" ''""• , """"' •' n-t-„n ■ m 1 1 1111 ... ri sis 11,1 - s ,. > 1 ... , ,, ' '■ ■- a ' ..„,,,,,.,, 1,1 luti ii„1 are 1.1 ■ ■ -,,,, iiiitl ohrjuks i„i i i -"", ; " n ; la ti-.a y,*r„u,e,,t .,„• .-,„■ - , nf f ' ., v . ■ d.'..g i-.-tiil.lish a euiisolid igover ," '.';-'-, . ' ;■ ra it oy |,,, cou nei i »"' '""' " "'""■ '«> vn .».•■" ■"'«:.... leh * powers rose v.n j ■ ■ stitulion out infect possetming all k.wer ich state to itself the residuary mass of ,, „ , . n ,.- a 1 c ... _,■ ■ .^. ., - .. .. . win *■?— serte ■-**--»■-, '-•'■-- < '*'' i • '■ • ■" ' . - -* ', "■ saiiiih i arolina vou have ii-ih.ii to tear ;■ ■ siutes the jairn-alis of the convention thai whensoever the general government , , uk „ „" l . whigs r - 0i vllll ma , ■ show that they did not wns then ever asstwies undelegated powers ua acta are ( , ( . i , | ,, ll ,„ i h such a political body ... tins country ... un^thontative void and of no force j that d ,!„,,,„.„,,, „,, h „ 10 11 „| ltll ,. v h ■ tne piutpleof tho united state in the.r to thu compact each state weeded aa a ( ml power ; i-lthough the selfish ■ i'i'ivp i rn 1 li is l.i-liru-,1 slate im i is 1111 mt si 1 part thnt this ' . ' . ... . ■ bcoi.li'.t 1 ix t i'll ■ " is ..,,,>>'', 1 ? 1 11 . iticiiins i.i th present day will do youh ■ ,,,,,,. ,,. r u il.ui ihimw-is lhe eon uveriuiii'iit created u tins eonipurl wns . •■ it 1 h ■ liii'ii'ii'ur w.i ii.ut iiiinii.isim ton - . 1 1 n lice : it time will coino when voiii'h h^i .,..,,.. 1 i'lhe i'ni.e.l stales liriill iii iii l ild i exclusive or llllill jiltl'.'e ol j .... . ■ li[illi.jn 1 uu t uu 11 . i.ii 1 ,,,,„..... ,,, ., i < n.,,1 y,,u inolit.-s mil fa'nn.recia.e.l.h hin ariaiani-n 1 1 1 l.v the ...•.„, i ill lli.-ir n ' >,' t"i t ,,. tlie power uelegalod i it .,, ii . ■ ht e nc ii nv tnc i ...... iu uioii nj . i i hi run will record vour at-n atl.lh h .... .,.,. r ll.'.i.v ■ uv hen llu i : since lliitt wail hav iiin.l us lis .„, . ■ h_-teua.i r . iii.i.iiv apai-uv nnn uu i tiu ily mil 1 lu-ln lo your iiiotiy.-s.h m , i a mi-iii 1 1'i'i'iuiieiii • tretion and not the constitution uu ni.-n .; r . ■ hti.oi'i iiint.iii is a i oum.i....u u i;,,v niiiiciii , ■ , i v i lav u nn.l a ilniiulloii with ninny olli ■ ■ . , ,, ,,,, , iitra.-v ih , , u-i iii hi u >- sure i is powers ; hu untl n m all cases -,, i i ' i h h it ou in , contrary llio cousin .- . ,.|- n..|,lc i-,,in|.:ili'i,'ts will i'.-,li in,l ,,:,,:,■ h .. ,„„,„., ,„■,,..',■,, v .,'.-,■., , lai.-s . lit of compact ainnna nai-ln-s hai-in-x no coin , ,. ,.-.,,■ ha uouipat i i uvt ii s.jvert.igu siai -. uiai.i i -, ... th ■• in-torn ni *,". anil the ell its ull !,:,,_■ __■,- __ i nnrniiom in.'nrrv in.i t'vi'c ii1"u iii e i.,'11 t us til rtl n^ill , ' , ■ h|.,r isifii.ii pin p.-s s io cany ui iv.iii i i i - vouaromakiua to preserve the coustiiu ■ h i 1 a.r .,.. t 1 ■-,.,,,-, then it woiilil to iuda-e tor tlselt us wc t itili-uctt<,:ri u-s , . ' . . ,, , ■ hii m iii ii joint designs in » u wuuiu i - uon and the rights of the states will >,,-■ ■ i il.ll.iw that llus i a eo.il'.'.l'l uj-.i ut tne uiodetiiid mei.sure nl redress . . .■ . i ■ h-..,iii io |, mow mai tins i a u ,, a.u o suii by the iiuct in liniiiortiil verse ■ hgovenitneut the oouatitution was form lu 17u-s the assembly of virginia adop . , r\|||'v i led by the states aa statea ; they voted as ted among olhers the following resolution ' v i status in the convention in forming that in which die undersigned hear ilv concurs on molionof mr wlontgomery.ol ilirtfj ■ instrument and afterwards ia us ratifica " that this assembly doth oxplioitly and fofo.m'e senate went mto a committee o ■ tion acted as states in their sovereign ca pereraptorilv declare that it views the the whole mr bp&iaht m'he chair uponb ■ cii there wn proposkioaa made power of federal government as re the resolutions reportedby the mint select ■ ■ iiuhe convention by the advocates of fed suiting from the compact towhlfih the epromittee^to wbomwha referred the south ■ ■ oral powers to make the g ral govern states are parties aa limited by the plain carolina dbcumenla i and after some tt ino ■ ■ rnenta consolidated empire thereby cau senae aud mtenuonnf instr il con i 1 " therein the speaker resumed tm ■ ,,, . the states lo heir the same relati stituting that compact si farthervalld chmr and mr spwght reported the rea ■ ■ the general government ihat the counties than thoy are authorized hv the grants lutien with wndry amend its v>.tn ■ now do to the states these propositions enumerated in that compact ; and thatin which the senate ttoncurredj and the re ■ ■ were rejected by the advooatoa of state ,- .- ofa deliberate palpable and danger solution su oded wore read tbe second ■ nghu who maintained thai tbe ibjects | ous exercise of othru powers not granted time and pasaed--«yea47,nooa7 ■ i'~,i,i lederal governmenl and the union h the said tiompact the states who are age messrs alison askew h.-ll ■ did not require that tbe states shnuld sur irties thereto have the riaht and are in brittain bullock collins du i | rr one particle of their rxmrnawt duty bouud tointerpnao for arresting the i 1 '-'- uotaon tfavin i all harrison ■ sovere.sntv it mil be conceded by the pnigress of the jsvil and for maintaining la.vltn.s lliutun lf.,-..-ui ll . houston i . ',„■,,. i siate ri_.hu that at tbe time of within their respective limits ibe author howell kerr latnb ulhnni ik l.in ■ forming tha constitution the states po i rights and lib rtiee appertaining to jaay thrahall martin wasaey m vu ■ sessed all tbe attributes ol sovereignly i ." this together with the reaolu lioffit moutgomere of o.v mixwe mor ■ „...! that this sovereignty resided io th uom adopted by virginia in 98 and their rie moye rd o moye of p norman i pie of each sun each state had s report and resolution of 99 embracing parham parker hay kbodes oenwell ■ v ntcomposedol leginlutire judi the km.tueky resolutions of the same yean sniul-ni • s i l '' i j too.ner vanhook w_l | c.nl aud executive deparnne . to each contain it is believed the political faith of der william wilsou ■ i'.v.,„„i were delegate.1 bt i e pe .,.!,-. in the republican party in tin « rtry if z zz ,'.'''' ' lr " ".- i in sovereign capacity oertan - lhen the states onaocoount of theiraover m'"**"i uattliews montgomeiy of u b powers to be executed by inem ; an-l yel eignty have a right to judge in tbe last re wellbora i it mil n t n mended that ti delego sort ami it is made their duty in case of friday ttec 49 ■ ti.ni fi-i • ,--: ■ ■ tu t-i separate mur : . i t-.-i to iuterpoae for the purpose of tbe resolution requesting tbe 8tate ol i .;.,,•■ governments deprived any u f arr"sting tha pregrea of fhe evil within south carolio-i lo suspend tb iperation ol ■ those slates of their iwtfnaswrr sovereign their respective limits with what propria the ordinance of their convention w li it should be borne in mind that aov iy oan these acta be called revolutionary in read tbe seoood tiam wr sfarfln niov b i,-i i,;v and government de not in tin their character wh.-n th-y are not only ad to amend the resolution by strikmg^out h.-oij.itry reside in the same body sovei rightful but dona with a view of arrresting the words until at least th*fli id h eign.v is unlimited power it is " unalinea the progress of usurpation 1 if tlns-iai.i september neat which waa agreed to ■ ble nii'l i eh i.i i '' reside in tlie nfjudging m tl.e last resort dues not vio and the resolution as amended was ruad i ,|,.. m | , v ., m ii v assemble in c nvan lata am proviaiou at the constitution bul the wc sid time i pi -.-. d i tion for th purpose f aaking :. new ■_- iv j.u the ntrary i consistent with tts-.ptr the bill to reduce lbe salary of the bu ■ ernment r of revising th«ir u-ganie law it and genius then tbe judgment pronoun preme court judges waa read tbe third ■ thev exhibit to the war i entire sovereign eed by a state must be aa lid and bind fime passed and ordered te be sogrossec b tv and their voice next i the x i rng i^kio the citisens thereof aa if the samo — kyea sft noea 99 boon must be ibeyad the qovaaa had boon pronounced by a tribunal appoin ayes messrs bullock cowper dl b mivr of he peopl is ppaivao ' '• - i thii led by the nonstitution it.-:--lf h tbe pes shongb pa.'soo cfavin hall harrison b v.-re:"ii body it iseompwed nf cer pla its itate meef io convention and an-l hawkins hinten ii k houston how b tein funouonariea posaessiii legislative ju uul an oneonatitutional aal pasaad-by ttmirlell llu ■>. i.,t lamb latham leak ■ h i;.i and executive power limited by own legislature.nopoe would question their j martin maasey matthews melvin loffit b a wn ten c-nstii.iti.il and slsraya undei right tn de so mueh lean wot.l.l the act be wontgoraery of i moore m ens moye h the onntrol of tba sovereignty nl lha peo brandedaa te»*olutittnary ifthe meal ul o moye of p parham parker ray ■ rl thaae aovereign states finding from in the same aapacitv and declare so un 1 rhodes spaight tyaon vanhook wah ■ ilie ie i hut cti...11 v-r r ail i l r..nsl.i,itt nal art ul the fe.l.'i.il i •_*,-! iture ik,i ,,. w 1 r bv-.i joint govern - n to their null and void and abaolve iheir u /..*,,- v*«a».*-*meesta allison aikew bailey ■ ',.>,. nl i...-1 *■ ' , in uu •■ i i : ' - ir from all bligatkias to ohey it having the bat*>i__an bell boddie irittain iiano h ... , i ,,. n t character i nod right to jo-f ftbo mode nnd measure of arter c.illio it.h ', ii n i btbu t-euvotuutiun of the u itewa xb . [ nit u ia not petceivod why rn latter 1 fcrtndaay t-vrsb«ll muutjomcr-y nf h n.i ii.i.n skinner spencei , slcdn.ai , il liams wilson saturday der "'», mr ill it i present i a lull hint lually to preserve tl.e piiritv of 1 i.-eiiona and tn prutot i the libei i nf tin ritia nsof thia stale which us read the tir-t tuno 7 it .':-*• /'•;'.' vc.1 rohtvi i v ,* / „„•-■ i irei ■ ,.< l po dollar per ,„„,./ «, '/,". -/."-, "-''' i "•- '"' ' ';•,. ,','.,',. ,/' mlill tl .,-..; ol . ;. , ,/,, ./",,-. \, paper will l nil tin urn : , i „, ''■ ion . ri^itton inim bt rt ■ ' ,' l i failure lo ij tl flit r q -', ,-, i a .) i , ,„ .. ... arnenrina six tolrent sn i ,....., ... ■, the t tr it ni tfi shall iture a . ',-,/„ ,- gratis \ i |{ ii a the usual rates .... to ike editor must „,,,, or ,.',,.■/ ".,'/ not be attended v.h pr.it i iniil rejected mr il u-ioit presented a h.ll to inenr rale the ciihaliil artillery 1....i mr iuvliins ii lull i'.i i'i ' hell i i n til of volunteers which waa re i the ii:"t time insm'd and the fn-t iml on lho it nilve i i i.n th ■ (.■ n \ ofthe siai .: '■.'..; i ( roliu i doth miter tain and doth unoqui *. i pn ■• vviirin attachment to tin cunstitiiti ifthe i uitl 7 slal -. i lie senaie then proceed tl to lake up tho i luii.u declaring tl attai inuetit i tin general usembl nl iin 8 it to the cuntnitutiea l lho i ni 1 s.ai •*, and resolved lha tho gnnornl assembly d.,11 soleinnlv decl irti u devoted ui a i the r,',i,',;il i uion boll ving ihtil un ii <-. .. . 1 1 it ... . <' .- do|h.ii ' '!.■ hi it v , tho peace ii'l prosiicrit of those i nil ,, sl lt,-s dim mu ine il.e doctrine l nullint ion and the resolutions having boon nu the ihird time mr w iis moved to utneiid ihem l,v inserting the following i 1 nmbl and resolution between lhe tilth ano sixth resolution and whereas hy h fifth article nf th const union oi the united slates it is provided that on iln iipplieu i of iwo thirds uf tbe several stales congress shall ull it convention f.r proposing a nd ments thereto and whereas it i ihoopiih ion nfthis general ass bly that tl.e raid on-tituii n in ids several amend ments restraining and roatneiuig the pow ,',-,. i'coiigrt -- and prescribing some tri bunal to dacide upon matters wherein the said constitution i:nl ine . uiistiliillolis nnd rii.jits.if il states may be brought i,,io question therefore resulted i'm ih ti'-nernl assembly does i,.\e make nu application lo iho congi-esi ,,(' ih united btates to cull a conventional 1 tfep * vi-i-i.l states to pr pose i ndimnta m jha constitution of the i in i stales resolved further that rw general assembly request that the li-eisfrivukea f lhe several states will make to i tt>k congress of me united states a ii.aiar - application hal the constitution t tho i nited states may i.e so amended a io restore peace an i harmony to the onli de cv pr veil u dissolution of the union a and perpetuate the blessings of liberty to us i:i l posterity w i ich nuu-ii.lnu ill was agreed to tha speaker voting in tho jlrrroative mr ili.il further moved to amaad the res lulu ns l.y striking am he third r so iuij.ni nn i inserting t*ws following " rtjjae rt .-.* -' •; ■ .'. . - ' : h^-'.-h - ■',_ ■■ of tiivx legislature that the prmwtr . .. r.h of dunes uie.os.rtl by the ( dhgress 1 ino ijini.il states is impolitic unjust oppress sive'hnd contrary to the spirit of the con stitution thai in this opinion we belli ve a very large majurity of the people of this stat concur aud that we hnve ui^ed and will continue t urge its rr p nl \\. i ich ■ j i ... i i was ti,,t agreed to i ho - these terms mill he strictly tidlu-r ad , ■• resolved that whatever diversity of opinion may prevt.il in this state as to the constitutionulit of the a is of congress imposing duties on imposts yet it is lie lieved a large majority fthe people think lho e acts unconstitutional and lie are ill united in the sentiment thai tho exis ingtariffia impolitic unjust and oppres sive ; and they have urged and will con tinue to urge iis repeal resolved that the doctrine 1 nullifi cation avowed by the state ofsoutb caro lina and lately promulgated in an r.li nance is revolutionary in ita chura er subversive ofthe constitution ofthe uni te.i si ites and leads to a dissolution of the i i.„i i^-takini^^ss^ri thursday d ■<-. 90 the senate proceeded t take up the ,. | a mt i lull making an appropriation . , ,: ning ,' iitii.i — toners for the re btit li ,'; of the cupitol „. the city nf ral ,, | ami the bill being road the second , ,- passed — we 38 noes 37 yeas messrs askew bailey bate man bell b he bullnck carson col i . uwper dish-mg faison harrison hawkins ii hon hussev latham lmd ,;,.. dell well miir.-iidl matthews mel vi .. montgomery ol 11 » montgomery of 0 moye of g moye of p nor .,, .. rhodes seawoll simmons skinner spa ht spencer vanh ok wilder wii lis ,'•■ wii ion va messrs lien lllison brittain carti r d ■',- i.gnvin hall hogan hoke houston howell kerr lamb leak lil ly vj|ii-ti;i d i-.-y hoffit moore mnr ns i'-irha n i'i k ,. ray stedman too jlier tvson weill nil mr allen then moved thnt th bill be rend t " third time which wns agreed to a •- : l '*-'" - 1 l - whereupon tin hill tva read ths third time passed and order c ,| ,., is enrolled ayes 8s noes 38 th vies n the third reiiiliu were ns on the second with tho exception of mr car bou who on the inst reading of the hill mule i ui lie i'tive t'rista liee.sl resolved that our senators in con gress be instructed and our representa tives be requested to use all ,• institutional means in their pnwer to procure on aujust ment of the existing trovcrsy between ihe stato of south carolina and tho gen erai government and i produce a recon ciliation betweon tho contending parties resolved further that a copy ofthese resolutions bi respectfully communicated by in excellency the governor of this sl tto lo lus excellency the governor of south carolina which wer rend lh firs une an i passed oo motion of mr williams they were committed to a committee nf the whole h.iuse nnd made lhe order of tin luv for thursday next ; and on motion of mr bell ordered to he printed _. t.i l-'lll j - • • the senate met according to ttdiourii uien ; and after the transaction of j.iiii unimportant business adjourned until to-morrow mr a-lt"w present •,! n resolution to gdiuuro nn the ith of january 1888 sine dr : whii h w s read and laid on the table lotion of mr latham it was n si.lveil that the commit h the judiciary le instructed to impure whether a remedy , , ! •,.,! be devi-e i tu prevent tin prac tice if issuing ca.isas in the first instance ajrninsi debtors having a sufficiency of visible property the bill to establish the bank ot orlli car ilitiawaa read the third time amended pa is i and ordered to be eogl-bsaed — ays bu noes 27 • ,., ».— m ssrs allen bell brittaitl cam i dishough ttinton hogan hoka hus-oy kerr lauih leak lilly l s-ty martin massev m hit marri *,! ii i imery ofo parker rhodes skin n,t 9 iifer stedtnan tyson vunhook l!l in wilder says — messrs allison askew bailey b i lie bullock carson llins paison lli.vi us houston howell latham mcdowell marshall matthews melvin motugotnorv nl h moore move of ('. m xi of pitt rav baawell simmons spuii'ht.toomer william's wilson saturday dec 1 wednesday dr 36 mr leak presented u resolution to un til , rise the commissioners tin the rebuild inn ofthe capitol te sell such pari of the rubbish ofthe former building us may he unnecessary to he used in the new build ing which wa read the first second and third tunes passed uud ordered to be engrossed mr bpaight presented the following preamble untl resolution : whereas it appe irs iv un tbe president j message ofthe fourth 1 this mo nh to the congress of the united stales thai tbo public debt will probably be extinguished early in the year ofour lord me thousand eis-ht hundred uud thirty three nml that lh re an now ,„, hand belonging to the united states funis sufficient i • pay he same and whereas in the said message he recommend to congress a reduction 1'tlie tariff to a plain and economical system f revenue winch rocomnienda lion we hope will i complied with bj the present congress ; but should out jail and reasonable hopes be disappointed wo t,ll have even reason to believe from the result ofthe elections for members ofthe next congress of the united siaies thai the tarilfwill be reduced to a revenue system founded upon republican princi ples nml whereas in the event of the pre senl congress failing fo in ike the proper reduction of the tariff we havo oyer reason tn believe the president of the uni i i stales will convene the nexf us soon as practicable after tht 1th day of march nest : therefore i solved i'liaf mr sister state south carolinn be respectfully requested to sus pend tl eralton and anforc t i . ,*. .,., | eve i ■ ■ i ,■ tu ' made or to ba .-. ,• irr ing into axeculinn tbe ordi na t har convention which may en 1 i the |. and harmony of these united status until at least the first day if september next fogive time t lha pr i sent or noatcougreas of the united states to act upon the subject ofthe tariff question then recurring mi the passage of the res i.tti , is the third tune tl \ ... re putt the 11 , use soverall and beiiarntoly ami passed then third read i i ... . i pl il.e preamblo and resolutions adopted on mr i ilsnn's motion to amend and ur.li red i > be engrossed tha l-t -.*■! ...- |,< last resolutions 1 sre adopted i.nooi the 3d by a vote of bu to '!: and the llh hy a volo of 49 tu ll monday dee the reaolution requesting th si.itt 1 south carolina to suspend tha op rait .. of tbo ordinance of th.-ir convent ton dt . was read the thitd time mr spaighl mov.-d lo amend tho preamble to sa .. olutiuoi by inking out tin wer.ls fourth ofthis month nml insertinc in lieu tluoe i i words four a dav of dec mber 1838 also to a hi the following as nt ad ditinnal resolution to wit " rea ived l..r titer that a copy of the foregoing resola i us be transmitted l.y the g-.v ri'tei f this state to the onveinor of the stat f south < arolinu ;" which amdhtltuenis w ire 1 to lr seawell u l turth r io amend the is mution by striking nut th f"l i wing words to wit to give limet tne pn ent or next cuugrass ifthe united states to act upnn be aubjecl of the tar ill which amendment wa ai agreed lo and tlie n li.ti.eis passe ,:- uincudedb h ou motion of mr vi alt hows it was ie tiiiit the committe finance be in ii.-ieil to inquire whether tlie sum of siv lutidred dollars appropriated by a res iiii,.,i of th last general asserabl foi -, , , :, \.'. for the use of tbo v eriiur ofthe ei.tp.te has been expended ; if u foi i lint and to « hottl pai i m.n.liiti lh ■ . 84 mr hawkins from the joint anient com • ii military afluirs to whom wa referred a resolntion directing lha t'."x • i to inan i i a ride carps for i -"' forming in the town i wushinitton nil nts belonging te the stato cii ut to arm said eutnpanj . in ide an unfavorable report ther s in which re port ihc senate concurred the bill to eiect nit uf n portion f the j - nf burke nud bimcumbea separ u iiml il dinct county bj tha name of \ oy i read th firal time nnd rejec i ay il nona •'••• hyts deaara allen allison briltain cursiat carter dubson hogan h-dte ilthistou k-rr leak lilly mcdowell martin l issei , m ffit mn-ntg un ry of • i i i ■". 1 „:-.-. parh , ,-. parker i i , nan i ui r tyson \ ai k »> ell born .**, ,,/.«. — messrs arkew bailey i '• - man bell bullock collins cuwper dls i i'ai-.ii gavin hall harrison hawkins hiutnu howell llu-se lamb l nl nn lindsay m u ha '. mattlu - -. i .,■,. montijouier | i'll m ive'nfg j m ye i f i'.i norman rh i li -. s.mm -■■ . 5 - i . \\ ilder wilhu us w.i ■ '/'. . j 1:111 i mr fa.-ter presented th following pre nil.le and resolution .- whereas by a convention on the part oftenneaae , north carolina ntnl south carolina beld t ash villi on the lirst honda i september 1839 it v,-.is then remit d thai 1 rail road l constructed fl a 1 the htnij f navigation upon tho holstein in t'.ie state of tannmsee along th valley , ffren h broad river in nona carolina to the head ■. navigation in bouth carolina ; and whereas the l'r,*-i deut filie dotted states has ordered a 1,-v of aud roueo and tha stale i andsoulh mlina have re spectiv ly made apprbpriatiooa io defray lhe expo s of aaid survey within their be it 1 1 irelore reeolved by ihe cspnc-nl assembly ofthe state of north carolina thai the nin of live hundred dollars is , in i tha samo i ; her i s prnpriated 0 tho route within the li its ef tin stele wlorh isere i 1 1 ihe tirst inn passed nnd i ttio.ion of mf fowper unlff-d i i i.h thursday iue.il on nation of mr alter the eoinmii-a .... u n tlie judiciory was inetructed i - ei 1 limine mt the legality of a claim ma 1,1 i ,!„. president ami directors of thej btale i ink by whiob tl.ey hav exacted ,..,, t f four per cant on the reeervedl rtock ii i paid f*u belonging tothe state in ii i hi il i , i i they w ■ further ,.,,,, .,.. | io iomiire by whal authority ., pr-widenl and l>i ectors i the v -« ,., i cape l"'-ir ba its pai th • net cent due the biatc upon ilia udividual b il forth r r olve i lh ■• the gov r f tiie siiji.i i . and ha i hereby au thwised to is«n<t ti:s whrts-i.s upva lb the en£resred lull coucuruing ciia.i