1 ( a \\ / , / > , y7 / , t4s .. ; .-— : ■ fefv v / — r < , a/-n i u h lish e d " v e e k t y li y a i i m a \ u h a i i t huhs d a ' \ , a p k i l i i8o?7 tnree i nw a n run • ! vol vi no 273 c0ngpes3 ■ oft hz united t ites lio'j e ')? repfci entativk tut-fcir.y f.r !(■. d la on tht hill rect'xved rpm tht .< tuif entiled " ••/' ■ ot to repeal at tain ■ ■(!■ r : . u-li'iv the o r g3-'iizatfoit j tie • '■> ■ ■ f lie u s.'rttt i . m . i i,o..i i'tn — i i ■■! h i iuia s i i-u'c ■'•. f <•- :. nr . n • ■ f i :!.••:• i-i n ' : \ ■. i i t . • . x . 1 .!>'.', '. , 1 . : ■ '. blc _■ ■ ' !• ' ■ ; ,:,, i ,.. r .:),,■...: . el "; '■ ■ i e ; i i ii •» m i i , . 1 1 ; i ■ ■ i . ': : i 1 ] , nij.lv i ■ ■ .■. li .. i,jj ■ ■ 1 ' i . ■ ■ ' i ■■ . . . c i i f i i .. i '•■■.■ i i'i i ■ . ' . ■ i ! . ■ : ■ . i lt u . . ■- ■■..., rt , . . ■ i ' • . i .. i , ■ . . ijui !■•.- ■•• d ii ; ••. ■ , , ■ ■ . ■ . ■, i ■ :: •: . . > . i i ' il 3 •* i ' ' ■ .\ i lc liil i fli'hl o r ■ ' . . r i ' .■■. i i ' • ic ■ iii o [ . : : '.. . ■ 1 i ii i ■ ■ ■ • i ■ i m ■ 1 1 ■ : > ■ . v |. ill llc ll kill ■ '~ .,.'., 1 1 1 10 lil i \ :<■ ■ '■ \ '■ i ■. '- >■ i .'.;,.! i 1 . ,. ■ , , , ■ • ' . mi ' . t k v • ' ' ' a .< ill ' . ' in ' ; . . i '-..•■ i i i l • v .. ,, , . « ! .- .■ ,\ . , ■ ii r ... a ut nil *■• '*■ " '*' • ' ■ ■ ,. ; , ■ , ,| ,,.;..•. jtiiin io in ui wh ' ■• •■ liorm i ■■ ii , vmli fi.i ii , ! .: , . ■ ■ v i i.»i 1 ■'■■' ■ j •■■■■ t ,,.- •;, i : ,.- . li'trn ion i .:... 15:1 hi ....... ; ,.. ■ . . i •'■.■.. i . iik'i ili.cli ih '. . ■ ho 1 fl .■:■■ ii 1 '. i !«. ih ■■ :' i • i u . i 1 1 .< ■ i ■ ■ • ■ ! > bcdiyiaet i > n , ,. . . , ( r ui i ■ 1 ■' !•'< !•> [) ifi ■■' ■■ -■• ■ i ; .■.•..;■.: t ■ i 1 ex m ii.i ' ,.. ..' •, i.i i i i i w u jfi j l.i ' ublfi .- ■. i wo ■ -' t iil < ii . a»or c meet i : . , : i i . . • ■ ;■■} rci ■ : . »■ ■■ i liem t e m 1 it , . i .-. i . - . '. •> sv bee i ulcd by : m .,, ,: ■ , win lieg v i'i .■ e fiul )>.'■• ■ lo ..!-. . io > c < •" mute t ' h g . fi fl a i j jmcl uliliecooll n:ioii wh.cli lut be-ji , . .,. mi lii 1 o ' ■■>'■ ilic f : i n i tioin . . _. . , .■ ,-. . i ; .•! imj bi e j c.icetl io ., ; .;. t ,, u . y ,.-. .:..: b cnl i :.■ u i,,j . i . a . . , , . ;■ ii f li'ii '■'■' i ','■■ i ' v " powcri i , ■ , , ..... c ii ■• i hull hav po if ex . iji ;,> • inlliiu ioti ic .<■ ;. axci to uormw iiii":c , . i r ' v 3 '■ ■' "'■,: ' y»riety •-.! i'c ■■'■• ,. 1 ; , t , , l m ,.;,.: • ..„ s iiifcnoi to il;c fupitme ... ) .... y - ■ ii .»' i.i '!• i : s \ .' ... j lud^io . ,. ji)v.ci iiwiyi ii:;brcctt j rtp.ali g pi ivei ; it ,..; . riijlvt io coul'iu.ac .■ urn lbcy ha en ; , i ;■■ . ■. ■ ' < j ihe ■ in ■. • . eta ituled ; ,, ,..-.: jso'i i is i.v.ii ■■, ■ diicrriionmy i i . . . ,., t . . 1 i ndulul lied as . . i it ll ii h '......: \: li ub.i i ifon ; ilic giarilii i . . , i ■..,.■ .. ' . .. :...• <■, lie i.i ii ... ,. .. i ; i .. ,- c'.v '■• . wei nuke the ijwi u |, . i . : ...;■.:. oi • • - .. ■■•, » r _ . .. ; j ! :•,. • t ' iu 1 iitf ijn : i o i u n g , v nj ii ■ ■ • ■ ; ■■ '■' ' i ui . ■ t t . v • » ; bive aiicaai '.■■■: c . b nrvci icn i ■ • ;. i i ■ .' . c - ■ •■ ■■ cl l!:clr c0i1cc fuels re ■>■ ; r liiuli ■ , a faitv l ■ ■ .. \ . ■. a :.' i : - - ' ,.'..- . r ;•..■.:; i t 1 c . uiution if-1 r usv it loiiiig to ilic jumci»ty »[• i ftl > . : ■.■!• i r c : ••• ;.■•■»! j!.:c fo j c t.llik vurlout iivkt li d undo htlc^r»i!icd pow i i . laiirg to ) ..■ ■..-(,!. . . i .. ; . , io • . ■ ., t i ■. mi n int be i/i i pi ■:■■,. i i e ei / ; •■ ' i n km w ■■■■'..■ ■ ' : . | ! i m ilit ■ ■ pow f < ■ h i t . .'...,".-'. ».;■.. i hi ■. • ■ '■ i , . \ ■ . . '"•.■■• i ii s iiic ii 1 . .. abiifi i .... o j 1 '!.■: -. ■'■ i ■ •■ ■' iiiy ing \ ■ :-. ih i , ■ . ; ■) ■ i . ■ ■ j i . r i'.i .. '. 1 .■ ; , * .. v i i a ',: vc i ■ v il upon ' ■ i ul "'•, ii ivili ; •• ( . i r . fi i i o my , ■■' ii " i ? .. •• . ! i ■ i'll . i.i . i . ; iii '.• ,■-.':■ .. . i 7 v t l i . . i tiicl .. • k '■ .• m i . -■ ', v i :.. . ; r.iiicuii co ' . ■ ■ 5 • • ■ ■ loio el i | uihcci i .-.. . . . : ... ■ ■ ; v ■.. v . , i i ii 1 i i c c,i ■ i in i ill idli ■ i i , i ■■•■■■'■ -■••■- i io inert n ]...■.. ii i .[ r id 111 ■ ' . . . . .. 0 pnia uul i hi ! . . ■ . c uio i pv luc for lh bri . ■ i , .• i bey have ii i on y i .. h i ihe ti .■ . ; i . . '■.. : < i j;jn '.■ '; i ■ .: a bo c i ii r . — '. ■ . . : i mil ■ mi ■ ii itv udgeii md i ; i ii.iu dm i ol ".!■' ri ol i lie i icoie '.. t '■ >' '■■■: i v ' ■ ■ i ■ ■: le ".....• h lul : : •. ■ if . i i a v ui i e puce cut tgifli'nre ii i .■ c'nn ii ficccdtni i,,,ili ic inlalnt!v — i i ii •■ . ui in juii more .. v ci . ■ com "• i llic tx'rci'e ul iheir tunoliui't than snv l*j;if i e ■■• li cb hi w them ii u a i mil t •:■ ■ ■ '■ ■ i i ■■';', nd ':' ihe iiti i »«• which ma irluli liom cxprncncc~it i » de i 1 1 i iliiy ot trrqi em tl choni ; in lulf i li i ■ ...';: ... ; ■ i c n i ■ . ■ . i i d u 1 1 i jrjj i ' . . . j ... ei cl'ilic i.i ! m .. hie h t have jull nom i ■ . . .■ i ..--• i oui 9 .-■: i lie bmi d i-:c i .... p ■•'-•• ol ni id tii j ion to tic in i sui fn , •■■ ". ■ . ■ un < hi .., ui . . it rue t : .' nt ii.cn fo i .. ; i ." . ! i j ...'. . j y txj . i h.ti , ir ■ •' "■ ■ ■ ih i e powi r t.l modilica ion ii ' ■ : ' i '.'...., ■■ ■■ f ii i mr-.cd it -' r ■ l v ...■ f , -.. i i.r.u iiom n >!■ . i i i i il goveim cm im i ' i jjtl ui i,ot ho din their ol i ' , "' ■ - u . v ■:. i ai d i ' ' '■■■' •< nhtm o ih r i : ' ■ ■ . te«j a i ■>' --...,., i .■ : ':■•■■■■.■ • ■ -■ . .;■. ih i l . t f !■ i nl r ' . . . , . ' ■ f ae :■...: •- • • ' : ■ .| ' ■'■ . il.il i 01 lh wi li vv : m they e rr.'r>:nchc ? 1 * '" u't t ( .■ man'j ow ft i .' r ll.i judge o ■"■' i . '■■: r<vn tl . • • ■ ■' cbei - 1 1 no ; entle »"> '•'•'• i . i mill w thl •' .-, w.-l v.'-'il'r ;..'!- c'.r'y wi(h the judi ■ > pouefs a duetnd ptoper indcpfi . the .: my ' . . ■ ikhoi •■■''■ n t adini i [ id .'■ ' , .. f ii iif , to n i ■ i ■ rl i o m i.i.-ir • )..-.. \ t i •> :• ■ t •! m r ■■. i snsiji.d i or the n..;.il h li - ■ .; c . r :: . ■ ..■ jhfll m ■ ihfl , or .;< uhei . ■ . ' -. i . ■ ling an nllv.e whenever it lji li ' • l:m j ■ ■ 10 ' hctti ii.i ■ ■ ■ . ■ i _ : ■ ■•. ■ ■ . . ■ f r > ■ ■ '...-. they m hoi t'neii ■ ..■■•.•. i .• ■ ■ •. : ifth*.ir !''■-:» c:;i ' | hi * cs t • ' ', . ■ . .. . ' ■'*: ..'..? is uxili delti oycrt tint is ■•■..■ . ,.• in low ef t.ut:i!liin ttii ufii e ;•.::•'::■'. ' - ■ i ; * fl e . i "• ■ i ?. : "■ i ' • . ! . > '. •■ wed thj ... ....' iuii '.;.. c > • ii iii .: •■ ■ ' ".■••.' nc'i * i miedged rd r ol m » n i ' ' •••> w wnole ... i ■ •,' fi 11 a i ' iiliil ■:■■..'.. the etf i | litiwti vt ich ii not given c •> i • . i » ■' . did ■'■ " , r i tium th>i which w ii i ■:■ i -.! by i'i in — t tuvi n ..■:,.". hi : , • ., 1 .:,.'.: till . s .: ,; * ■. . ■ ■ i ., i ■ . , , iiufii i n i:k ii'iitli • ni'ioni it iiai ' do i kriieil '•■,-< >' ' ;'•'- ' ' '■■ '■' ■'■ ! ' ■'' :' '"' ■' . i i i i i ..... . l i • ..> .■••■■ wire nov better i in . .«. ltd nil in an the ctl-rti i hi i d itinttin i ■ i ilw y . j-.ci r,i i js t3 dc i ft'-d h rr j«ii.:r.':e . e ',:!,, .,.■ i ruth i ii i if m iu ■;< npcu-i ::■'..,!■, 10 .,■'■.•■■'-• i •••;•.■..'',.. i i ll)c ■' l:*4i u .' jiii t i i om w»i a i i ■ v fc i tin the iiiirofl u i toil ul ioidi . litr nd i i ■!■.. it n n ol the i ii rm i i-.cncc lcine tin \ ii ;.: t » ■ ' ! .. . m ; • : » ii .*. j oi il - u li . f)l "• iv'liat i j ■ i illi f ii 1 ' ■!' 101 ; 1 i ).. . it i . i , ■.. ■ .! i i ':■- i ' i ' ' l tdlcs hi i t-c .... :,■. i.o fu c.nc court n.'l laili iulcr tor d u . i ■. . c'.i ihall liopi ti in i timi ordain anj ef iiulifli " congiel n.n til i t>i cu i'l mjy • i)t l.i i>m urgct.iti c nruiin n<i cibb i ourti isut il iliv i j iilli l.u t !■!'... i c y tliey anolilh .- 1 ti 1 1 » . into hst o v iii'c ■ ■ ■ :■ i ■ i ■. hull we b plunged t «(.• rrj tl.n ic if j'nijic intcrjjrela tion ? i n '■','■' i to ify ll:e l*w biing toiilcj'-d i.iu no 1 1 • 1 1 i o i ■ rr - the ;!!■;■* o th.'ii ofli l.i uui cau ir v i i rxlii it u l,)tfl cl v/lurh .: ntuei l)3i vi t i u'ri ivcvci vul rxhibil — i ! a wiihnut clj'i ct j '■■; > wi li t cumii i pnvntd ». t oi.ifj oui t tin tc th 1 ltiu i:'j'i!l tut t n f r ; ing ucprifed ol theii i icy tjunu lie in pc ii 0 ) it k ill ir i ir . ii i : the i it fu ,■ ac rfi.o i . i ; io uivic 3 loi their f liriet i tlyi fie rrsjuirg (>■ f ■ o iitilui oil wl ich u ■• \ ■ i •■!, i.'ii •' tin j ucig-j cuimgtheii continuance in v ■■!':. il receive i c i pi.-tihtio.ntoi thrii icrvi i---i com icn.'iuon :" hut i . ■ .. >■'■ . w . ch tiri.lbui i ii . . t ■' t ji ii rlu i v ; vn_i -_ ; uppt>fe ih'.ra t:e oo fervii ■ iqi tt.lni to prrfoirn v i ai :!.;%. :* n t 1 iut ijwyocai ■■ r a'lil lie judge fay to the irgilluuiei in-.u^rc idyoaii.j jkc tnc n .-.'■■ rtion»ic ;.' my j • y j.ri ! i i [)?■ ' ■■ ,> i ui ? >'•'&: id mr •..:.... .: ■ n uici.'a'.c u . , u s i cvr ovjccleu to ; a utiiin ' ' ■■ . uu y s nevti ibjctlfd to ; bit it duties it hilic-i :, i iici mult t.u ic iuctciicli .' i iimiei land inc v.^rd ton 1 j-tif ioii it fi^uirki i nn . mg jjivcn t.;i ai imcthitig p liormed liul t there be : <; hut peitormcd jnd il tlieie be i.o i t . then tan n i duty u .» tlir i-b ..: to b no i mpci idtion iii'.^c ''•.',, iil lengua ethsre liiuch'a no ds fintciire i'liis ii a >. id m . churtnin wjhicli hj ] ■ : \:: i ■ ■_• pi ■..:'...■ i.i ■ i'.'.aiul i ..! is < word i . ■ tc i to the fpi it of oui conltitution y.t iir n the ■ [ ■ ■. r i the conllitutiuui wliiih is uuw contended or br 3.!;r ; :: ii ihll wi.l be a w nd wi^ic'u wo fitai'i foon pratlua!l ee.li a.i'j jir»£lic»hy unaeifla id weftio h»ve a fel il men rcc ivii .. i t f public trcauitji .■■:. tncgof'derttion ct pi ic icrvicei v j • j t without a ervice whatever being pti \>-, i.i ; ii ::■ winer m i i *<- hall lay lh,c found lion '.' i liia-c .■; fyfttm the c lequeocci it v.-..r br \}\ . ir.i.»lj'c tud ■ . cli ol win ii v ill oc i ct i il ;:' ldti\f oui ii c n j •"•!! ii;ew yo t ; a p f-rhen & .; rtc'ufit oi ..!:■:: l'j itgifliture u a dff«t • .;■ tonll ' u ibe aoultitulion ; i will he ...;.■ .. i ■■. it i federal cnogrdj i^.r mi i , ic . . i '■''. ■ t lielin f to exercifc thr ; r .. . . . ■ ■ i lr>r j by ihe j 7 1 li ice ol the !»•*• ■ ; i ' ■• . 1 ■ * ii.li i imt im«i <- cation before to ad veil '■ ... '' '■■■■ '•'"■' f >'■" abo.ilh 1 1 h«n that cutler m'ij tliouijlit thimfclvci jullifiijsl , in touching 1 ic ;-».:.'•■ interior couiti tin 1 , ol i i fupiemc > urt il.ewife i lei you will had ttui j i nc iw . 1 1 li ontl ituird ll.e i'jptcme rmirt i i . ■ i 1 ■ , a ;...'.; s i,t ii i ■ . 1 , iti u n i-i t ■ t dcttiei ui olli . s hat i 1 peiiorm um du i j 1 i ■ t ■ i'liift 1 ol the lupiemc 101 r s n in thj i dtf.i ml ai-.i to fil'i|'i lie ;!■...-.- 0(9 j'.i'ij cil 1 1 c in : court a it likcwtli d fim-d in 1 iiw ; ! jr.-i in aboli hi ng the tircn it 1011)11 h 1 ihe otfici ol the judgei ot the fupieme 1 iui vr.r • he i 1 rlujil mr chminuo t coi it 1 luu 11 i>rcai i a light 10 t i.h thi \«.' •;• ■ . c ■,, . ,. •■.■-, o lhce j 1 but if i thatwaain inti ol ti.e 1 ni.u : n or wl ether .■ w u ti 1 nlia6 .,■ 1 i e yconll tuliow lo abolilli ih •- ;. c lajnd e ot the lu prcme c urt ! v ill no m u uet n \ j iu enquiie becik/e ii s^ucaii io.cj but lii'.ic upon the iuiiut d tatc tut jeet ii oi iii il rut ■-..■:; tin 1 c 1 in <;! the bill ailu-.'dci ndtt.to ntcilcii v ! be fli emlthe j.i t;c i't he fnpremecauitfurtbei t ha tn rcltort hem 10 thai li ., that tightlu . tint c*nltiiu i mal grounu l which they rood pievioudy 1 1 ; <■ t tlie iw < ■ ■ ijii fcflioq tnd to ail ih dntici uu i«n iniinic i ji v i.i i mod iiucccelj wifti lo uc tlic:n redo red uut mi chtirmm the gmtler-.an liom pcnnfil vinit h>i lolormed uii t u icknowlcd • < 1 ih lam of toe lilt icih.'ii is coudituti nj ; in ... • lean by no mcaa'i s&ta with that gentler . 1 .. c n mic ftfli n in that law ir uliich 111 ■ • ■ ic o ptnh . ■ 1 djgrtflt violalioii t th . . -. pi ll.c y^th lift no lhat aw ;!■■ :\ 1'iitt c u ol iv «" 1 t n 11c tee i • •-■ . .' ! pitili ■ - 1 ;.•! • '. 1 ' 1 ■ s ; ■ ' • • r i ... . i,o :'■■■> c « "••".■;" - ■ ■ 11 l i : ■ r bait r a iikj would . v done no h'jie in y nn we now contend we have a rijht to 1 1 . .;.- ■■ .■.; '.:.:. .:■■■[' cv llturped a dowd in it opinion noi gi en in by 1 conauution the tfurp d j -. . ■»• 1 e.xc ufivcly vetted .« the prefi liebt lad . • . .!: :.".'.. a ol the i(tc jw ill j'ici;>e.i of'h'dii t - t'j of kenttlckey mi venn 11 ■ an appoi . .: .■ m judjrea in dfl i » ■ ltd ■■ ■ ; i ■ 1 i . ' i i k ulii the dutici f h ■ - ciij'il ■ lie v ill it atiigned them — 111 li.t'ift e i in t . key nt j tturtcflec j c i i cil ' ..' i r i fh u ie i:>'-iitic(t if they si no circuit jndgta to ill • r i s i pvrpofcii in i i wv i ft forlh ■ i be lai'iim i il ill are o'en nil judgea i .!;).■» ini-rl bj the k'lj'fl ■ ;■ , and in dii«£t yiyl •..,, ! l that ar'ielt of the omllitu ion which i in id i mull ex|irti tenu , v jic-i tn t power in ihc irffi ' rtcat an fertile r ■!'. i ! i . rchi 1 !.• , in n ro,n p-.iiifyli'inij ■> i.»',h when i iii •'■• i l.ttnt'f ti ■' i \ jjd||<i d.;cl bui uv.l l.i c mft tu ic duly •' ' u t ? tb'ti'n tnri-m 1 •■ • • .• th.il y cx-m lificjt i-i . - ijuli 1 betold t t by ihe l.w ihey sra fti.ed dif tnfl judg i ? how i m cli innaii ire we to ['■: impoletl in h duiid h-v long arc vit to be en | aii^lcct wit theeobveb l i si ill v but lir :!•; ' ccoticnjlii llci'll votth-cj ■ :• :•.•, wji 1 ui |.. icmiilj ivii.u'd ut ag in'k viol n of lhe i !• inn hiii!u •."-,!• ii'inber ol ihin houfr when t!\c law which 5 »•, j i i been ' ■■• kin ;■■' ij ? i picnic iy your j irrnlj i :,. w ■: my then r wcie no 1 . i i ■!' ■ c i ' itlo s wli ch hi i w ex rricnen wu;i fuclicxmi i f fo.'iilj i t , o l j eneri ? w.iv nee they nr>i mv«k !':•»> t sga ■. raigll n.-:h 1gs i rivr 1 iii .:'.! i i .; .'„ ; i . n ,} l . ui i.i'i 1 i aik ic lio ora^ie i»e i in v i wihi * facie egi ius luud i i viul wo in i v.s i rl t •! i tii ■ en : iii 1 •. i h hi i it'ed n > p'an ativc cry n f ■• -, oh ! ip ic t e coiuitn ion ol 11 . country > v iciday 1 , hr jeni cman i.il ■• i u 1 lllf •: i ■,:, , i.,i,u ill 11ui v li i,r w u i heave no fi^h hu wpu d dio j no tear qvc 1 1 ii ■ '••.,;-. ■ • j cooil ul ■ when i i law 1 iftuil j nr hc-ive no fiui n e drop 110 ir»i ? oh no fi vi 1 y hut cot * 1 the ci'u ic w m i».i wai then pui ■■ i wnh c ou'i wuh cmtl dclibcr.ui'in the dc^o rd *,■_ 1 i ki k m i.ii(md tt iiiit lit . , od vt inch i flu d from ■'■ r f/i'ig wound win torevcr ii.m tue page oi yout mi • c i nin the expediency of the law now i::iiii " ■' ■ ■'< iri 1 ; h d ii iii 1 • ■ ■ v il adopting a mcjtuii i ih:6 na u'c ai the | lrr,t imc lij'.t been i.j lull ui o i . . 1 - l ; j ; . : y <: ! . .; ., , 1 i c | n ij c ,, o t in 1 n.v »..;■>, 111 t rr-rrin rrviu i ih.i apply but fe » a;ion 1 iming 1 otn s a c where j if ice i 1 1 !■ 1 .-.-.- 1 kvah prompiiii'ji and in . i , 1 conli-fi u*i p .,; .,, oom fiurie ol t'c io 4 i j«il iar.,e».cuci my aftoml^mcni i uad fir fup , ii tljt the da'inrii v ,,.'■> has been i u • n i fh e i hv wcv iif.ve wuu i be t in i md ct>mplc*t i i'wei to anything !■., u.u.u uid on tini divili.ia c ihitu i l ; but fir the gentleman li^..n penn i v<i,'j mi il.j'in . iu thaijl he undecided uu ■ f trii la.'eofm 1 land were add j the aggie e te imnbci i . t iciiiiff c ulv in tli conrtj ct the ' i.'-.m-,i ii:iiis vcu >, probably an u.11 to fixu . handled a><d the ctiqu ici il it ii prj".hc a ble loi he ccuin ills tin rep'ji i tlir g-,v ofuie lull !■■ j 1.1 iu drtei ii'.-.e ilii number f caufes ilj.i .■ • vei the imuid ;-: ti ir when i ; ,■ , ,, - ,. ' ol i pjto.ii.ick and call to my rccei t on ■ ',:'.- . ; 1 .! : 1 1 v c . . • iflicd in iny countiv j ctiinot helia:e a moroctil in giving him an j:.r • v i;i si 7 11 c 1 ir mr chairman ror was it p.-.fiiiilo ' ■■ m 10 pioiuie ducunienlkh rr ihr i hli ct c , ur : , my itate 10 ihexr to hi 1 m i.iun ii :■•,, - ait whiciiu c;.fn irr la 1 mi but iir wl u i 1 flcil how in 11 i 1 1 » v .■ freii a vcucr-iole cituen ri iiijl tta;ir eiju-ci c hir hit great learning rtl efr lie loi i.ij ircptoa.hable life and retpeifiable i jr h.s ■ years .'. .-.. , ; i irv full ievcnl who i»j rlg u in ■ 1.1 ni >>.: i of cluneeiy there devoting hit days ia ;.■;: nign : : jic avocatiom ol hii i.liicw in ■.: pain rti"wl i common cii r.cn dif p'nliug iiti i ..■ mil fniilitflnn 10 li.e molt lu^i'i jl u izeni h ir caufej are died before its iril 1 . ni ; when i icfleft ! in ihe nun bci ofdccifi ill wliich treinue in hia court in tie cjiufeof a year ; aiid when i overlook « documrnt wi.ich i n»f now i my pflltifion iryrti ihc c eik of ihji cmi it and which 1 dial i pie j lentxy t.ffer n die view ol thi coinmit.ee i ,. a n hd\t no diftii iliy in rnnou ling thi iiicere opinion wtiicti 1 c.-iti 11 that he pcrlo 111 1 more du ., and jjctl..pi i 1 eatrr ability than the whole iuiii i.ial coipi o ihc unt:d states kt-id t\c d'oc iuiufro»n the cic'h ol the liigh cuua ol cliancciy of asd w'nat mr chaiim a is the comjtenfition wl'.ii to 1 venciati 1 cii zen 1 itivri i tilt ••■> him jiul do.'lari — 110 :: ore — inipa'e ih s with the fuia wh ch fuppbiti and decoratca luc fail compotne co ' lu'n'i vii.cn we are inloimed 11 one i u.c i'm i pilliri ot oui government j and to tope h •.-.!. nil v.e an 1 il will occafit n the beau iful fabnt to tutnblf ■ 1 , :',.:■. dult k-v v c uoi hate ci..i la diftuf il 1.1 1 i bundance nvci cveiy cornmooweilth 1 mipofmg t i 1111110:1 i a;e th.yi.i competent to ihc decifi n .; a i c j ic 1 01 ton 1 , in vr ley bet wee citiz-.u mu citizen i wheie then wia the o:ccftity ol thr law 1 the all fciti.jn which laimhcd aiul u.cicjf il ihff couiti } ■ liu fir ih honortble geu icmari iron north j . - lina 1 icund in ii;cr u'v lor ti-.l lie i 4 i t!-.ii m ( '• ihe'people when ihey ■■ d thu conftitut i 1 ci : no d icf,a r tnc jdv i oi leg flation to ihe houfc oi iep:efeni«tives ilone fhc eltab ilhed i».c :;. ' njic ii 1 cat k up - si the h ir vi reprelentalivci iiow.ii nit noien n;,utfi which otlcn actuate p - • t u 1 kllrmbliei they >;'■■- the prefideut r>o n.e r ow <.! 10 negative lawi when a law hid pa!!\j he e v^riuut branch so the 1 1 became ic celliry to ci 1 6t < triia department ci a il r i ciary act holding tbeii office dunng p'eifutr but oaring •' good ctiim.>ur ' — 1 [ i i conipiehendtbear jjuu.nu ol ci.:icititn v.hcn i i pofed it iv:nt 10 ihe eft.tblilhii.eni ol t ii department >> a ch < . :• j'i):i the legifluaie nd did^i thf n-gurni 1 oi ike iintunmn irom pennsylvania wii;a 1 j cited j ii^c i'j cif-t charge which i have not ir-o ii :;> v.'iu ", n i " j i noted tj^ele woid " i i u it to i ii iluty ul he .... 1 1 ., l^^li ca.r i it care the uw null and void 1 ' i ( i live not mif .. i.iiii.ood ihc g.m.t.i.j ,; oauumy eyei are oow j . pcucd 1 u 6 ui to tel onje nl thefe app ' a . v :. ch h.vc liet'ii fa ii on|ly t litcii iboi.i j ,.:.:. 1 j hcretofett 1 have not bc;ri jeeuito 1 ed 10 pciici.«.e i o,,lu,tiam » leu 0 ufui^aiton of p •. ■ • ■ - pirt r ih \ ■■ i'li n — for they e l.'»nni || v rrf pni.fi'uli i r it wlruntnii lur ihc ucrtd obfei vi t ol the hj 1 of t t'..k >■ ; i;',i i:,from a '■. 1 ..■ 11 u r i , :. . : i we on he pan of the execu tive for tin t»:f m of hit fervice 11 limit ed la loot yciri sn t rr lore he ij iijl e t i w h : • fiice in cifc ol in mfin-cu.n of tile conlllttliion on lili p rt ; but fia i i mine w ich lie i ihii chick drpnt ni i ol ilir government u iu g'tfp at all power — give i!ie j"j iiciary il>e check upon the ir flour i • low ihr-m thn pdwci i declare your l*w null and v .!, il or i he common l»w • hjlcci extending to all prtluns and to ill tiling ip be att ched n ihe i ' . ii'i.i a i undctftiod it it crtl'cnded ; aid ■ vji.i inn th people pi ccd you upon tint floor to icgiui'c ; jotli idv.t tvii be iu.!:6rd your p ncerd i .. .« "■'!! '< checked ailoi n the office rxifu u rr ho dj ii durinji gi on belnviour ; lie it ih n iili tn icnt beinf iiiricxndc t lid pot hiving tl i degree ol rei mfibiliiy much j tj ia cifs:e c.i ituiucheci ;•! the legifli me or lo th execu i ••, rbe powei gianted by i r • conttitution lie 0 be il irtly conll.usd , noihinn i lobe left to implica tion ; no innji to niiifl ution the uti.-r i to dctcr !.■!'.( the extent .! their power and 1 conceive it »"■ vei w ij intended they ihoti d lismfcead ii — ih'vri lit looked into tlir couilitution with a ftrutioiiing tye to dilcern if p tible wh ice thefe preleofioni cedtiivej i i it ■ e at r but two cl^ufei ol the ton ii i i»i!i wh u ii c ii ■ . ptet«ncc lc tn p-,wei wliich is eonte ded icr the i.ift it >> fol ow : ' rhe judicii fower of the united statei fh?li x cod tu sh cal tinltwind equity it fi g ondei ihia conftitulion tht i vs.lih umted ' tate nd n its mice ur vthicli ihtll be m<d under iheii m t on . " — i ci i i ■;>!(. « aw null md void f ccitiia ly i iy fui h a c it r lie i m li^m in i i y t uifing urta dei iii conftitm t.n its nil contm p*uil to b em bi r j by i>ii patag iph i have cited ii will lie in 1 in to u , thai wit njut i - ii a conptucl en the con it iuiion i.»iii t it ui i tied itm not now to ic«fu tl.at there a c two ocunptioi.i ol cslet wlijch v ii bis ul \ iihi in io latiily ■ l.c trirni ilitrf cxprefled in i lie i n in ill i sun it where cxlei fh ill anfc be iwer ii vittteiii ol diitcuni ilittt oi beiwcen citixena in inn n i whiih ai to be decided tuherb t)>>e hw oi by loieign aw | o whtie calca hi.il atifj between cttizmis ol the lame ilaic in cotifiq lencc of mi u iconlliluti jinl txcicilc ol powci on u.c pin of iih 11 ic ni einiti ng and nick rig v ill ol c'rd't i id.il inn . 1 ;■_■ o.l ti cl bt ot ihr tonltiiiitiua i a loi v : " 1 ' i ennituuiion iu i!-.c 1 •»» of d tci v . liirli hil be made in putla<nc ii c i i . fi .. i tin r.;i;tiu itw vit oii laid -'■' be i.i ,; i i e finll be bcuiid iliftc b i , ., ■• my liom the v uids vt\th which u i ■■ • ■• i ■> '• ■ <■ i inftiutlion oc dn.ition to tl j .. i i/l . . • .. . .• ouiit j ana it they rre • il in te ii v conn un cue "•■ ' • ' ' • ' i ii ' ci , t end iii i - lii form 1 1 ■■■ j ■ •«.- • y ii ■ hull ■■;• :. iid by ihii co i ■ ■"•""".■'• " ij ihrri ■. nalunable ctfon dr i ' hijixol lion wil lay ilia by either or by '■ ' ule il ul'ei a ; own ii g'li-u in yout judi t , tu decuic l : „ v 1 uu i t*.r void ? tley iti a y • ' ■, ( i a tvliilt impede ihc palfage ul a law • lion agnitill iis coi hitmionaaty | rt no - imp th law it ir loi e i not nullified and . i . cl •. upon iv i evei iii<-reisa ch nge ol ■ — ", ■'■ i ii iti.idutve cxe-titive ni ju ici»l di , i ■■• " : • f n !..;•;•!-.,..■.; ,;,•; diftinf — rhia '•" '' ■ • uccoins <■.! axiom in poliuca ihlt they 1 1 ill yet i enquire illiliij c he i • 1 1 , if you alii n to me j l.licuiy the pc<vei to annul ynur lawi in i ciinceilc i nt the common law is ittachcd ■ • ■■■ ' •' '"' ' i am pcrfi a ed you hereby toi centtate a pi •■ ~> in one department ihe cm moo law is th cunlliiuiimii and ihe coait may it iticy pie i . c j i it vjit l ii i bavr ji heard it explained whethei he common * .■. j ,;, without itaiu ory ai^endmenu — ui ii common law with tlatutory mendnicni5 or with what lla'utorj amend nenntj i to be attached to tic louttil ition ? 1 bdie%e it is intended ilicy lnvei light toapply fuch parts ol it as a;p!i i luc io ui . conftiiutiou lheccmoion l»w extend to all pcrlcmi and ail tbtngi riiejdgith vo the light ol adopting lint law ol inch pttliai it.fy deem sp plicablc { they can m ul yonr lawi it ibcle pov crtare ieal;y comended io on the unrt ui ihr judi tuij and il thelc poueri h ud tver be . oiilced they would wiihou doubt ported munlimilted end uncsnuo i bis powir ol lepflajon i ar lice lot niv own part iu define i!:ji i i id raihei liv under the government ot a lemsnt del oi this ucli a go verora in ol i ii t <». and i thofe powen ire le lly contended toi 1 leel no i.efnilio.i m in inning y u mr cheirmin vbit ihii t ihe tree whrre ucfpotifni liea concealed and ihii too ii tha aulpi ioui mo : • n . - henthofc i :■ chfi ihould he j;m,icit i«>y 1 i oi late himc vrgttated iih eztraurdinny lux uncncy bui,ii,,iiu lore i with yout uclmc lop i 111 lamili.ilion nd luff me ftriocfi in enquire v v . v u th conlrqutnce 7 t uverftia ow your tx ciuive tepu ul j oui loil will ber.oma ioo ueulc lur ilic puin ol libcuy ; i,u a-itllplitie will ut imiutea v ill ill (,(> ii i u ffi.v 1 ., «. d 0w i . . g eagle will lall ccao t in i ol ( i " be continued j rtphal uf taxes t'n commit te tj h'ayi and meant ivbv r uc>e ihllrudi .. to tn^uirc to ihe t^ye d;tncy ij reptainig i ,- laws laying tiu ti-i on it ii unditeme/l c tlijtilitdjpirits en refined j>*g ■' s i t ■ «, ,• i i-j > e,o /• / ;, y./.vj at aiciion p'.i jnr»blt car tinge s } j i nped vellum pu>ch»nnl t.rd aptf % and pr,lty,ge on nut paptrj tj ibi sii in/lunt r r .- o t t tl i ibi lio rr.i mt el revenue iii(i»g i-'tu hole duitei cxciulive oi ..,':•.. on u«wt-p.iptu c i by tne ftitemeati ud before lie m ..;■., by '■. cctetary of the tiealry in the eaily rlage oi il d a oe tx.c«d lot ibi itai ii-c gaj^ooa